Margaret
PearMargaret
Origin/History
Raised by Christopher Wiegel, a German nurseryman of Cleveland, Ohio. In the middle of the nineteenth century, Wiegel planted seeds which he believed to have been from a Seckel pear. From the resulting trees he selected two for further trial "because of their early coming into bearing, their upright, vigorous habits of growth, profuse bearing, and good quality of fruit." In 1866, Wiegel named one of these "Mary" but later changed the name to Margaret. First published references appear in the Horticulturist (1866), American Pomological Society Report (1869), Downing's Fruit Trees of America (1869), Missouri Horticultural Society Report (1890), and Guide Pratique (1895). Hedrick notes the variety was a "one-time favorite still rather commonly planted" in the early twentieth century despite its defects, but considered that "better summer pears can be found for New York, and for almost every part of the country."
Tree
Downing describes the tree as a vigorous, upright grower, productive, and an early bearer, with young wood dull reddish. The Central Experimental Farm catalogue (planted Spring 1890 at Agassiz BC) reports it as "a fairly strong grower and productive."
Hedrick (Pears of New York, 1921) gives the fullest account: tree medium in size, vigorous, spreading, somewhat drooping, open-topped, productive; trunk shaggy; branches brown mingled with much red, overspread with thin gray scarf-skin, marked by numerous lenticels; branchlets slender, long, with long internodes, light reddish-brown, streaked with ash-gray scarf-skin, glossy, smooth, glabrous except on the newer growth, with numerous small, roundish, raised, conspicuous lenticels. Hedrick's Cyclopedia (1922) summarizes the branches as medium in thickness and smoothness, brown mingled with much red, marked by numerous lenticels.
Hedrick characterizes the trees as "hardly more desirable than the fruits, since they are tender to cold, blight badly, and are short-lived, seldom attaining full size" (the 1922 Cyclopedia adds "or large size").
Leaf-buds small, very short, pointed, appressed. Leaves thin, with margins tipped with few pinkish glands, finely serrate; petiole green; stipules of medium size. Leaf dimensions differ slightly between Hedrick's two accounts: Pears of New York gives leaves 3 in. long, 1½ in. wide, with petiole 1⅛ in. long; the Cyclopedia gives leaves 2¼ in. long, 1¾ in. wide, with petiole 1¼ in. long.
Flower-buds small, short, conical, pointed, free, borne singly on short spurs. Flowers showy, large, in dense clusters; Pears of New York gives flowers 1⅛ in. long with 6 or 8 buds per cluster and pedicels 1¼ in. long, thick, pubescent; the Cyclopedia gives 1¼ in. long with 6 or 7 buds per cluster.
Fruit
Size: Downing: small to medium. Hedrick: medium in size — Pears of New York gives 3 in. long, 2½ in. wide; the Cyclopedia gives 3¼ in. long, 2¼ in. wide. Central Experimental Farm: medium size. Hedrick repeatedly notes that the fruits "run small in size" relative to other summer pears.
Form: Downing: oblong obovate. Hedrick: oblong-obovate-pyriform, irregular. Central Experimental Farm: obovate.
Stem: Downing: medium, inserted without depression. Hedrick (Pears of New York): 1½ in. long, thick, curved; the Cyclopedia gives 1¼ in. long, thick, curved.
Cavity: Downing notes none ("inserted without depression"). Hedrick: acuminate, deep, narrow, russeted, furrowed and compressed, often with a pronounced lip. (Note: these two accounts conflict — Downing reports no depression at the stalk, while Hedrick describes a deep, narrow, russeted cavity.)
Calyx: Downing: large, open; segments long, reflexed. Hedrick: open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute, reflexed.
Basin: Hedrick: deep, abrupt, furrowed, often compressed. (Downing does not describe the basin.)
Skin: Downing: yellow, mostly overspread with deep dull red, with small russet dots. Hedrick: thin, tender, smooth; color dull greenish-yellow, often with a deep but dull reddish-brown blush and occasional patches of russet; dots numerous, small, green or russet, obscure. Central Experimental Farm: greenish yellow, with dull red on the sunny side.
Flesh/Flavor: Downing: white, juicy, vinous, sweet, good, early. Hedrick: fine under the skin but granular and gritty near the center; tender, buttery, very juicy, faintly vinous, slightly aromatic; quality good. Central Experimental Farm: white, juicy, sweet, vinous, quality good. Hedrick's general assessment is more critical, noting that the fruits "in neither flesh nor flavor can they compete with the product of several other varieties of the same season."
Core/Seeds: Hedrick: core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube long, wide, funnel-shaped; seeds large, wide, plump, obtuse or acute. (Downing and Central Experimental Farm do not describe the core or seeds.)
Season
Downing: August. Hedrick: matures in late August and early September. Central Experimental Farm: early August. Hedrick characterizes Margaret as a summer pear, early and attractive in color and shape.
Uses
Not described in source. (Hedrick's accounts treat Margaret as a summer dessert pear by implication but do not specify uses.)
Subtypes/Variants
Not described in source.
Other
Hedrick's Pears of New York includes a reference to an illustration (fig. 80) in the Horticulturist 21:172, 245 (1866), and notes that the variety was earlier figured in the same volume (Horticulturist 21:78, figs. 43 and 44, 1866) under the name "Mary" before Wiegel changed the name to Margaret.
Book Sources
Described in 3 period pomological works
Nursery Catalog Sources
Found in 6 catalogs (1891–1901) from Alabama, Illinois, Missouri
- Missouri Nursery Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1891
- J.V. Cotta (Cotta Nursery) , Carroll County , Illinois — 1898
- Alabama Nursery Co. , Huntsville , Alabama — 1900
- Central Experimental Farm , Dominion Department of Agriculture, Agassiz, British Columbia (under test; Bulletin No. 3, Second Series) — 1900
- Benjamin Buckman (personal inventory) , Farmingdale , Illinois — 1901
- Mountain Grove Nurseries (Tippin & Moore , Proprietors; Geo. T. Tippin, J. W. Tippin, J. C. Moore), Mountain Grove , Missouri — 1901
View original book sources (4)
— A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)Margaret.
Raised by Christopher Wiegel, Cleveland, O. Tree a vigorous, upright grower, productive, and an early bearer. Young wood dull reddish.
Fruit small to medium, oblong obovate, yellow, mostly overspread with deep dull red, small russet dots. Stalk medium, inserted without depression. Calyx large, open. Segments long, reflexed. Flesh white, juicy, vinous, sweet, good, early. August. (Hort.)
— U.P. Hedrick, The Pears of New York (1921)MARGARET
- Horticulturist 21:172, 245, fig. 80. 1866. 2. Am. Pom. Soc. Rpt. 53. 1869. 3. Downing Fr. Trees Am. 811. 1869. 4. Mo. Hort. Soc. Rpt. 35, 36. 1890. 5. Guide Prat. 68, 279. 1895. Mary. 6. Horticulturist 21:78, figs. 43 and 44. 1866.
The fruits of Margaret are early and attractive in color and shape. This is about all that can be said for them, as they run small in size, and in neither flesh nor flavor can they compete with the product of several other varieties of the same season. The trees are hardly more desirable than the fruits, since they are tender to cold, blight badly, and are short-lived, seldom attaining full size. Despite these defects of fruit and tree, the variety is a one-time favorite still rather commonly planted. Better summer pears can be found for New York, and for almost every part of the country.
In the middle of the nineteenth century, Christopher Wiegel, a German nurseryman of Cleveland, Ohio, planted some seeds which he believed to have been from a Seckel pear. Out of the trees grown from these he selected two for further trial "because of their early coming into bearing, their upright, vigorous habits of growth, profuse bearing, and good quality of fruit." In 1866, Mr. Wiegel named one of these Mary but later changed the name to Margaret.
Tree medium in size, vigorous, spreading, somewhat drooping, open-topped, productive; trunk shaggy; branches brown mingled with much red, overspread with thin gray scarf-skin, marked by numerous lenticels; branchlets slender, long, with long internodes, light reddish-brown, streaked with ash-gray scarf-skin, glossy, smooth, glabrous except on the newer growth, with numerous small, roundish, raised, conspicuous lenticels.
Leaf-buds small, very short, pointed, appressed. Leaves 3 in. long, 1½ in. wide, thin; margin tipped with few pinkish glands, finely serrate; petiole 1⅛ in. long, green; stipules of medium size. Flower-buds small, short, conical, pointed, free, singly on short spurs; flowers showy, 1⅛ in. long, large, in dense clusters, 6 or 8 buds in a cluster; pedicels 1¼ in. long, thick, pubescent.
Fruit matures in late August and early September; medium in size, 3 in. long, 2½ in. wide, oblong-obovate-pyriform, irregular; stem 1½ in. long, thick, curved; cavity acuminate, deep, narrow, russeted, furrowed and compressed, often with a pronounced lip; calyx open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute, reflexed; basin deep, abrupt, furrowed, often compressed; skin thin, tender, smooth; color dull greenish-yellow, often with a deep but dull reddish-brown blush and occasional patches of russet; dots numerous, small, green or russet, obscure; flesh fine under the skin but granular and gritty near the center; tender, buttery, very juicy, faintly vinous, slightly aromatic; quality good. Core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube long, wide, funnel-shaped; seeds large, wide, plump, obtuse or acute.
— U.P. Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)MARGARET.
The fruits of Margaret are early and attractive in color and shape, but they run small in size, and in neither flesh nor flavor can they compete with the product of several other varieties of the same season. The trees are hardly more desirable than the fruits, since they are tender to cold, blight badly, and are short-lived, seldom attaining full size or large size. Despite these defects of fruit and tree, the variety is a one-time favorite still rather commonly planted. Better summer pears can be found for almost every part of the country. In the middle of the nineteenth century, Christopher Wiegel, Cleveland, Ohio, planted seeds from one of which came this variety.
Tree medium in size, vigorous, spreading, drooping, open-topped, productive; trunk shaggy; branches medium in thickness and smoothness, brown mingled with much red, marked by numerous lenticels. Leaves 2¼ inches long, 1¾ inches wide, thin; margin tipped with few pinkish glands, finely serrate; petiole 1¼ inches long, green; stipules of medium size. Flowers showy, 1¼ inches long, large, in dense clusters, 6 or 7 buds in a cluster. Fruit matures in late August and early September; medium in size, 3¼ inches long, 2¼ inches wide, oblong-obovate-pyriform, irregular; stem 1¼ inches long, thick, curved; cavity acuminate, deep, narrow, russeted, furrowed and compressed, often with a pronounced lip; calyx open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute, reflexed; basin deep, abrupt, furrowed, often compressed; skin thin, tender, smooth; color dull greenish-yellow, often with a deep but dull reddish-brown blush and occasional patches of russet; dots numerous, small, green or russet, obscure; flesh fine under the skin but granular and gritty near the center; tender, buttery, very juicy, faintly vinous, slightly aromatic; quality good; core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube long, wide, funnel-shaped; seeds large, wide, plump, obtuse or acute.
— Central Experimental Farm, Central Experimental Farm, Agassiz BC — Catalogue of Fruit Trees under Test (Bulletin No. 3, 1900) (1900)Planted Spring 1890. Tree a fairly strong grower and productive. Fruit of medium size, obovate. Skin greenish yellow, with dull red on the sunny side. Flesh white, juicy, sweet, vinous, quality good. Season early August.