Beurré Diel
PearBeurré Diel
Origin / History
Beurré Diel originated as a chance seedling in Belgium. Most sources (Lindley 1841, Hovey 1852, Hedrick 1921) attribute its raising to Dr. Van Mons of Louvain/Brussels, with Hovey dating the seedling to 1805. Bunyard (1920) and Hedrick (1921) specify that the seedling was actually found by M. Meuris, Van Mons' head gardener — Bunyard locating the find "about 1800, at the Chateau of Perck near Vilvorde, which once belonged to the painter, David Teniers," and Hedrick placing it "near Brussels in 1805." Van Mons, finding it unnamed and of fine quality, dedicated it to his friend Dr. Augustus Frederick Adrian Diel, "one of the most distinguished of the German Pomologists" (Lindley). Downing (1900) likewise calls it "a chance seedling near Brussels, Belgium, dedicated by Van Mons."
Van Mons sent scions to the London Horticultural Society in 1817, where it soon after produced fruit (Hovey, Hedrick). It was first sent to America by Thomas Andrew Knight, in a liberal donation of scions through the Hon. John Lowell, to the Massachusetts Agricultural Society in 1823 (Hovey, Hedrick), from which it became generally disseminated throughout the United States. The American Pomological Society placed Beurré Diel on its fruit catalog-list in 1854 (Hedrick).
Budd & Hansen (1914) note it was "much grown for market in New York and Michigan." Hedrick (1921) observes: "The variety is still being planted, but there are better autumn pears." Bunyard (1920) writes: "A pear which is still very largely grown despite many detractors. As well finished in France it is delicious, but in a cold season it is only fit for stewing."
Tree
Sources broadly agree the tree is vigorous, large-growing, and productive, but differ on certain particulars.
Vigor and habit: Lindley (1841) calls it "a free grower" that "acquires considerable size." Hovey (1852) describes it as "very vigorous, with the lateral shoots horizontal, and often curved when young, but, as it becomes older, assuming an upright and tolerably regular form," and notes it is "one of the most vigorous and beautiful growing pear trees... valuable as an ornamental tree." Elliott (1865) calls it "vigorous." Downing (1900) says it has "long, very stout, twisting branches, and is uncommonly vigorous." Thomas (1903) describes shoots as "large, spreading, irregular." Bunyard (1920) says "Growth, very vigorous; fertility, great." The Central Experimental Farm catalog (1900) calls it "a strong grower."
Hedrick (1921, 1922), notably, gives a more restrained assessment: "Tree medium in size and vigor, spreading, open-topped, slow-growing, hardy, productive." He further notes it is "uncommonly vigorous and fruitful, but very subject to blight; it is characterized by its long twisting branches which need to be pruned back heavily."
Bark, branches, lenticels: Hovey notes "smooth, clean bark." Hedrick (1921) describes "trunk slender, smooth; branches slender, twisting, reddish-brown mingled with grayish scarf-skin, with few lenticels; branchlets with short internodes, dark reddish-brown, smooth, glabrous, with few small, raised lenticels."
Wood (young shoots): Lindley calls the wood "long, strong, flexuose, olive-green, with a few scattered oval spots of an ash colour; at the ends covered with down: when old, becoming light gray." Hovey describes wood as "Grayish brown, with large, oblong, grayish specks, strong, and moderately long-jointed; old wood, grayish olive." Elliott says "wood, olive brown, with grayish specks." Downing (1900) says "Young shoots reddish yellow grayish brown."
Buds: Hovey: "buds, medium size, broad, rather sharply pointed, erect, the ends curved inward, with prominent shoulders: Flower-buds, medium size, ovate." Hedrick: "Leaf-buds obtuse, free; leaf-scars prominent... Flower-buds large, long, conical, rather plump, free."
Leaves: Lindley: "large, either roundish or broadly cordate, smooth." Hovey: "Large, roundish ovate, largest about the middle, shortly pointed, nearly flat, thick, dark green, finely and irregularly serrated; petioles, medium length, about one and a quarter inches long, stout." Hovey also notes elsewhere "large, deep green, glossy leaves." Elliott: "foliage large." Thomas: "leaves roundish or broad." Bunyard: "Leaf, large, round pointed, irregularly serrate, sometimes finely, sometimes very coarsely." Hedrick (1921): "Leaves 2½ in. long, 1½ in. wide, oval, thick, leathery; apex abruptly pointed; margin finely serrate; petiole ¾ in. long." Hedrick (1922) gives the petiole as "1½ inches long" — a discrepancy between his two accounts; the 1921 figure of ¾ in. agrees more closely with Hovey's "one and a quarter inches."
Flowers: Hovey: "Large, petals round, cupped, with a rather short claw." Hedrick (1921): "flowers open early, nearly 1½ in. across, showy, in dense clusters, 7 or 8 buds in a cluster; pedicels 1⅛ in. long, pubescent, greenish." Hedrick (1922) gives the flowers as "1¼ inches across." Veitch's Fruit Trees (1911) notes: "the tree is a good flower and very productive."
Stocks: Hovey: "It grows very freely upon the quince, and soon acquires a good size, producing abundant crops." Elliott: "Grows and fruits well on Pear or Quince, but is best on Quince." Thomas: "Succeeds well on quince stocks."
Bearing / cropping: Universally praised. Lindley: "Its great merit, independently of its excellence, is its fertility, both when trained on a wall and as a standard. In the former case, it will succeed perfectly on an eastern aspect." Hovey: "producing abundant crops." Elliott: "very productive." Veitch: "very productive... Is a good bearer." George Bunyard & Co. (1914): "Pretty good prolific; productive. Fine for walls and standards." Hedrick: "uncommonly vigorous and fruitful, but very subject to blight."
Fruit
Size
Universally large. Lindley: "when in perfection, it is 3 inches broad and 4 inches long." Hovey: "Large, about three and a half inches long, and three in diameter." Elliott: "Fruit, large." Downing (1900): "Fruit large." Thomas (1903): "Large, sometimes very large." Budd & Hansen (1914): "Large to very large." Bunyard (1920): "large." Hedrick (1921): "large, 3 in. long, 2½ in. wide, uniform in size." Hedrick (1922): "large, 3½ inches long, 2½ inches wide, uniform in size." Central Experimental Farm: "Fruit large." Veitch: "very large and excellent." George Bunyard & Co.: "? large."
Form
Lindley: "about the size and figure of the Summer Bonchretien, without the protuberances of that variety; it is much swoln a little above the middle, going off to the eye either abruptly or gradually, and tapering straight to the stalk without any contraction of figure." Hovey: "obovate, slightly irregular, large about the middle, full at the crown, and tapering to an obtuse point at the stem." Elliott: "obovate obtuse pyriform, surface rather uneven." Downing (1900): "varying from obovate to obtuse pyriform." Thomas: "thick pyriform, neck short, obtuse, body very large; small specimens approach obovate." Budd & Hansen: "obovate." Bunyard: "round oval, tapering to stem, even, always, however, showing a certain flattening at the sides." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "obovate-obtuse-pyriform, often irregular and usually with sides unequal." Central Experimental Farm: "obtuse, pyriform."
Stem / Stalk
Lindley: "strong, woody, 1½ inch long, inserted in a deep, funnel-shaped hole." Hovey: "rather long, about one and a half inches in length, stout, curved, and deeply inserted in a contracted cavity." Elliott: "stout, and slightly curved." Downing (1900): "an inch to an inch and three-quarters long, stout, curved, set in a rather uneven cavity." Thomas: "an inch and a fourth to an inch and a half long, stout, moderately sunk." Budd & Hansen: "stalk stout, curved, and from one to one-quarter inches long set in uneven cavity." (Length given as "one to one-quarter inches" — apparently abbreviated and possibly meaning one to one and a quarter inches.) Bunyard: "very stout, ¾ in., nearly always curved, in a very slight depression." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "stem 1½ in. long, thick, curved."
Cavity
Lindley: "a deep, funnel-shaped hole." Hovey: "contracted." Elliott: "narrow." Downing (1900): "rather uneven." Bunyard: "very slight depression." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "obtuse, shallow, very narrow, russeted, furrowed and uneven, often lipped." Thomas: "moderately sunk."
Calyx / Eye
Lindley: "close, in a deep cavity, surrounded by knobs, ribs, or broad protuberances." (Note: Lindley's "eye" here refers to the calyx end.) Hovey: "medium size, open, and considerably depressed in a ridged basin; segments of the calyx long, narrow and projecting." Elliott: "calyx, medium, open, long segments; basin, abrupt." Downing (1900): "Calyx nearly closed, and placed in a slightly furrowed basin." Bunyard: "Eye, open, segments erect, in a small irregular basin." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "calyx partly open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute."
Basin
Hovey: "ridged." Elliott: "abrupt." Downing (1900): "slightly furrowed." Thomas: "slightly furrowed." Bunyard: "small irregular." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "shallow, obtuse, furrowed and uneven."
Skin
Ground color and finish: Lindley: "when the fruit is first gathered bright green, changing in a short time to a bright orange, with little trace of russet; occasionally it is spotted with russet; and its dots upon fruit from standard trees are usually surrounded with red." Hovey: "slightly rough, uneven, dull green, becoming bright yellow when mature, occasionally russeted in irregular patches, and sprinkled with prominent russet specks." Elliott: "dull green, bright yellow when mature, russet specks, and scattered russet and greenish brown patches." Downing (1900): "rather thick, lemon yellow, becoming orange yellow, marked with large brown dots, and marblings of russet." Thomas: "dull yellow, with numerous conspicuous dots, and some russet." Budd & Hansen: "yellow at maturity with numerous large brown dots and patches of russet." Bunyard: "rough, covered with large russet dots and slight russet. Colour, dull yellow with a slight red brown flush in favourable seasons." Hedrick (1921): "very thick and granular, somewhat roughened by russet markings and by dots; color lemon-yellow, with a faint pinkish-red blush and markings and flecks of russet; dots many, russet, very conspicuous." Hedrick (1922): "color dull greenish-yellow changing to lemon-yellow, with a faint pinkish-red blush and markings and flecks of russet." Central Experimental Farm: "Skin yellow." George Bunyard & Co.: "pretty golden yellow; dark golden."
Hedrick is candid that as grown in the eastern United States, "the pears are dull and unattractive even at maturity when the pale lemon color is brightest" — in contrast to Lindley's and Hovey's brighter "orange" and "bright yellow."
Flesh / Flavor
Lindley: "clear white, a little gritty towards the core, but otherwise perfectly tender and melting, juicy, with a delicious, rich, aromatic, saccharine flavour, without any perceptible mixture of acid." Hovey: "Flesh, yellowish white, coarse, slightly gritty at the core, buttery, melting and juicy: Flavor, rich, sugary, highly perfumed and delicious." Elliott: "yellowish white, rather coarse, especially near the core, juicy, melting, perfumed." Downing (1900): "yellowish white, a little coarse-grained, especially at the core, but rich, sugary, half melting, and, in good specimens, buttery and delicious. Very good." Thomas: "rather coarse, rich, sugary, buttery, juicy, fine." Budd & Hansen: "creamy color, quite fine except at core, buttery, sweet, aromatic, and when well kept delicious in flavor, very good." Bunyard: "white, melting, a little gritty at core with a delicious flavour when well ripened." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "yellowish-white, firm, becoming tender and melting, quite granular around the core, very juicy, sweet, aromatic and rich; quality very good." Central Experimental Farm: "yellowish, a little coarse, juicy, sweet and pleasant." George Bunyard & Co.: "flesh white, very juicy, buttery and sweet; one of the finest flavored autumn pears."
Several sources qualify the quality with growing-condition caveats. Downing (1900): "in every respect a first-rate fruit in favorable situations, but on very young trees and in cold soils it is apt to be rather coarse and astringent." Hedrick (1921): "When the tree is happily situated as to soil and care, the quality of its product is excellent, its fruits being delicious and ranking among the very best, but when illy suited to soil, climate or care, the flesh is coarse, the flavor insipid and astringent, bringing the quality down to second or third rate." Bunyard: "in a cold season it is only fit for stewing."
Core / Seeds
Lindley: "CORE very small, with narrow cells. SEEDS usually abortive." Hovey: "Core, medium size: Seeds, medium size, dark brown." Elliott: "core, large; seeds, dark brown." Hedrick (1921): "Core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, plump, often abortive, acute." Hedrick (1922): "core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, usually plump but quite often abortive, acute."
Sources thus disagree on core size — Lindley calling it "very small," Hovey "medium," and Elliott and Hedrick "large" — and on seed dimensions, with Lindley and Hedrick agreeing seeds are often abortive, Hovey describing them as medium and dark brown, and Elliott noting only "dark brown."
Season
Lindley: "Its period of maturity is the end of November, and it keeps well till the beginning of January." Hovey: "Ripe in November and December, and keeps till January." Elliott: "October to last November." Downing (1900): "In eating, in this country, from September to December, if picked and ripened in the house." Thomas: "Late autumn and early winter." Bunyard: "Dessert, October to December." Hedrick (1921, 1922): "Fruit ripe in November." Central Experimental Farm: "Season October and November." Veitch: "Fine for late use Dec. & Jan." George Bunyard & Co.: "Nov."
Hedrick (1921) further notes: "The pears keep and ship well." Lindley likewise: "keeps well till the beginning of January."
Uses
Primarily a dessert pear. Lindley: "It is of the first rank among dessert Pears." Bunyard: "Dessert, October to December" — with the qualification that "in a cold season it is only fit for stewing." Budd & Hansen note it was "much grown for market in New York and Michigan." Veitch: "One of the finest pears. Fine for late use." George Bunyard & Co.: "Fine for walls and standards" — confirming its use as both wall fruit and standard tree, as Lindley and Veitch also remark.
Subtypes / Variants
Not described in source.
Other
Disease susceptibility: Hedrick (1921, 1922) notes the tree is "very subject to blight" and that the long twisting branches "need to be pruned back heavily."
Training: Lindley specifies that when trained on a wall, "it will succeed perfectly on an eastern aspect." Veitch and George Bunyard & Co. both endorse it as good wall fruit.
Keeping and shipping: Hedrick: "The pears keep and ship well."
Reputation: Hovey: "If the epithet of a noble pear belongs to any variety, the Beurré Diel unquestionably deserves that appellation. It is a noble fruit, in every sense of the word." Bunyard (1920): "A pear which is still very largely grown despite many detractors." Hedrick (1921): "The variety is still being planted, but there are better autumn pears."
Book Sources
Described in 9 period pomological works
- Downing, Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)
- Hedrick, The Pears of New York (1921)
- Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)
- Bunyard, A Handbook of Hardy Fruits (1920)
- Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)
- Budd & Hansen, Systematic Pomology (1914) — listed as Diel (Beurre Diel)
- Thomas, The American Fruit Culturist (1903) — listed as Diel
- Hovey, The Fruits of America (1852) — listed as THE BEURRÉ DIEL PEAR.
- Lindley, Pomologia Britannica Vol. 1 (1841) — listed as THE BEURRÉ DIEL PEAR
Nursery Catalog Sources
Found in 13 catalogs (1845–1917) from Arkansas, England, Massachusetts, Oregon, Washington
- Winship's Nursery (Brighton Nurseries , operated by the Winship family), Brighton (Boston) , Massachusetts — 1845
- Hovey & Co. , Cambridge , Massachusetts — 1849
- Azell Bowditch (Nursery / Fruit Catalog) , Boston , Massachusetts — 1850
- Woodburn Nurseries , Woodburn, Marion Co. , Oregon — 1894
- Kelway & Son , Langport, Somerset , England — 1897
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1900
- Central Experimental Farm , Dominion Department of Agriculture, Agassiz, British Columbia (under test; Bulletin No. 3, Second Series) — 1900
- Yarbrough Bros. , Stephens , Arkansas — 1901
- James Veitch & Sons , Ltd., Royal Exotic Nursery, Chelsea, London (also Coombe Wood, Langley, and Feltham) , England — 1911
- Vineland Nurseries Company , Clarkston , Washington — 1912
- Thomas Rivers & Son , Sawbridgeworth, Hertfordshire , England — 1913
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1914
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1917
View original book sources (12)
— John Lindley, Pomologia Britannica, Vol. 1 (1841)THE BEURRÉ DIEL PEAR.
Beurré Diel. Hort. Soc. Fruit Cat. no. 95, p. 159. Diel's Butterbirne. Diel's versuch einer systematisch. beschreib. in Deutsch. vorhand. Kernobst. vol. xix. p. 70.
This noble Pear was raised by Dr. Van Mons at Louvain, and by him named in honour of Dr. Augustus Frederick Adrian Diel, one of the most distinguished of the German Pomologists. Its great merit, independently of its excellence, is its fertility, both when trained on a wall and as a standard. In the former case, it will succeed perfectly on an eastern aspect. Its period of maturity is the end of November, and it keeps well till the beginning of January. It is of the first rank among dessert Pears.
The tree is a free grower, and acquires considerable size.
WOOD long, strong, flexuose, olive-green, with a few scattered oval spots of an ash colour ; at the ends covered with down : when old, becoming light gray.
LEAVES large, either roundish or broadly cordate, smooth.
FRUIT about the size and figure of the Summer Bonchretien, without the protuberances of that variety ; it is much swoln a little above the middle, going off to the eye either abruptly or gradually, and tapering straight to the stalk without any contraction of figure ; when in perfection, it is 3 inches broad and 4 inches long.
SKIN when the fruit is first gathered bright green, changing in a short time to a bright orange, with little trace of russet ; occasionally it is spotted with russet ; and its dots upon fruit from standard trees are usually surrounded with red.
EYE close, in a deep cavity, surrounded by knobs, ribs, or broad protuberances.
STALK strong, woody, 1½ inch long, inserted in a deep, funnel-shaped hole.
FLESH clear white, a little gritty towards the core, but otherwise perfectly tender and melting, juicy, with a delicious, rich, aromatic, saccharine flavour, without any perceptible mixture of acid.
CORE very small, with narrow cells.
SEEDS usually abortive.
— C.M. Hovey, The Fruits of America (1852)THE BEURRÉ DIEL PEAR.
Beurré Diel. Pomological Magazine, vol. i. pl. 19.
Diel, Diel's Butterbirne. Dorothée Royal, Grosse Dorothée, Beurré Royal, Des Trois Tours, Beurré d'Yelle, (of some,) Gros Dillen, Dillen, De Melon, Melon de Kops, Beurré Magnifique, Beurré Incomparable, Sylvange Verte d'Hiver, of some Collections. } Hort. Soc. Catalogue, 3d Ed. 1842. Fourcroy Bouvier, Thompson, in Gard. Chron., 1845.
If the epithet of a noble pear belongs to any variety, the Beurré Diel unquestionably deserves that appellation. It is a noble fruit, in every sense of the word. Of the very largest size, — of handsome form, — with a deep yellow skin, — a perfectly melting flesh and luscious flavor, — and ripening late in the season, when there are but few good pears, it must be considered one of the very best which has been added to our collections.
The Beurré Diel was one of the early seedlings of Dr. Van Mons, and was raised as long ago as 1805. He first sent scions of it to the London Horticultural Society, in 1817, in whose garden it soon after produced fruit ; and it was first sent to this country by Mr. Knight, in his liberal donation of scions, — through the Hon. John Lowell, — to the Massachusetts Agricultural Society, in 1823. It was named in honor of Dr. Augustus Frederick Adrian Diel, one of the most distinguished German pomological writers.
The Beurré Diel, in addition to the high qualities of its fruit, is one of the most vigorous and beautiful growing pear trees, conspicuous for its large, deep green, glossy leaves, and smooth, clean bark, and is valuable as an ornamental tree. It grows very freely upon the quince, and soon acquires a good size, producing abundant crops.
Tree. — Very vigorous, with the lateral shoots horizontal, and often curved when young, but, as it becomes older, assuming an upright and tolerably regular form ; annual wood long and remarkably stout.
Wood. — Grayish brown, with large, oblong, grayish specks, strong, and moderately long-jointed ; old wood, grayish olive ; buds, medium size, broad, rather sharply pointed, erect, the ends curved inward, with prominent shoulders : Flower-buds, medium size, ovate.
Leaves. — Large, roundish ovate, largest about the middle, shortly pointed, nearly flat, thick, dark green, finely and irregularly serrated ; petioles, medium length, about one and a quarter inches long, stout.
Flowers. — Large, petals round, cupped, with a rather short claw.
Fruit. — Large, about three and a half inches long, and three in diameter : Form, obovate, slightly irregular, large about the middle, full at the crown, and tapering to an obtuse point at the stem : Skin, slightly rough, uneven, dull green, becoming bright yellow when mature, occasionally russeted in irregular patches, and sprinkled with prominent russet specks : Stem, rather long, about one and a half inches in length, stout, curved, and deeply inserted in a contracted cavity : Eye, medium size, open, and considerably depressed in a ridged basin ; segments of the calyx long, narrow and projecting : Flesh, yellowish white, coarse, slightly gritty at the core, buttery, melting and juicy : Flavor, rich, sugary, highly perfumed and delicious : Core, medium size : Seeds, medium size, dark brown.
Ripe in November and December, and keeps till January.
— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)BEURRE DIEL.
Diel, Beurré Royal, Melon de Kops, Diel's Butterbirne, Des Trois Tours, Beurre Magnifique, Dorothée Royal, De Melon, Beurre Incomparable. Grosse Dorothée,
Foreign. Grows and fruits well on Pear or Quince, but is best on Quince. Tree vigorous, the foliage large; wood, olive brown, with grayish specks, very productive.
Fruit, large, obovate obtuse pyriform, surface rather uneven; color, dull green, bright yellow when mature, russet specks, and scattered russet and greenish brown patches; stem, stout, and slightly curved; cavity, narrow; calyx, medium, open, long segments; basin, abrupt; core, large; seeds, dark brown; flesh, yellowish white, rather coarse, especially near the core, juicy, melting, perfumed. October to last November.
— A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)BEURRÉ DIEL.
Beurre Diel. Beurré de Gellet. Dillen. Dillen d'Hiver. Des Trois Tours. Dry Toren. Mabille. Gracioli d'Hiver. Beurré d'Yelle. Fourcroy. De Melon. Guillaume de Nassau. Melon de Kops. Beurré Vert. Beurré Magnifique. Beurré Incomparable. Diel's Butterbirne. Diel. Dorothée Royale. Grosse Dorothée. Sylvanghe vert d'hiver. Beurré Royale. Dorothée Royale. Gros Dillen.
A chance seedling near Brussels, Belgium, dedicated by Van Mons, and named in honor of his friend Dr. Augustus Frederick Adrien Diel, a distinguished German pomologist. Its vigor, productiveness, and beauty have made it already a general favorite with our planters. It is in every respect a first-rate fruit in favorable situations, but on very young trees and in cold soils it is apt to be rather coarse and astringent. The tree has long, very stout, twisting branches, and is uncommonly vigorous. Young shoots reddish yellow grayish brown.
Fruit large, varying from obovate to obtuse pyriform. Skin rather thick, lemon yellow, becoming orange yellow, marked with large brown dots, and marblings of russet. Stalk an inch to an inch and three-quarters long, stout, curved, set in a rather uneven cavity. Calyx nearly closed, and placed in a slightly furrowed basin. Flesh yellowish white, a little coarse-grained, especially at the core, but rich, sugary, half melting, and, in good specimens, buttery and delicious. Very good. In eating, in this country, from September to December, if picked and ripened in the house.
— John J. Thomas, The American Fruit Culturist (1903)Diel.* (Diel's Butter.) Large, sometimes very large, thick pyriform, neck short, obtuse, body very large; small specimens approach obovate; skin dull yellow, with numerous conspicuous dots, and some russet; stalk an inch and a fourth to an inch and a half long, stout, moderately sunk; basin slightly furrowed; flesh rather coarse, rich, sugary, buttery, juicy, fine. Late autumn and early winter. Shoots large, spreading, irregular; leaves roundish or broad. Succeeds well on quince stocks. Belgian. Fig. 693.
[Additional entry in this volume: "Gros Dillen", pp. 793–793]
Gros Dillen. See Diel.
— J.L. Budd & N.E. Hansen, American Horticultural Manual, Part II: Systematic Pomology (1914)Diel (Beurre Diel).— Large to very large, obovate; color yellow at maturity with numerous large brown dots and patches of russet; stalk stout, curved, and from one to one-quarter inches long set in uneven cavity. Flesh creamy color, quite fine except at core, buttery, sweet, aromatic, and when well kept delicious in flavor, very good. Much grown for market in New York and Michigan. Belgium.
— E.A. Bunyard, A Handbook of Hardy Fruits (1920)BEURRE DIEL. Her. Pom. II., 66. G. Diel's Butterbirne. (Belle Magnifique, Beurré des Trois Tours.) Dessert, October to December, large, round oval, tapering to stem, even, always, however, showing a certain flattening at the sides. Skin, rough, covered with large russet dots and slight russet. Colour, dull yellow with a slight red brown flush in favourable seasons. Flesh, white, melting, a little gritty at core with a delicious flavour when well ripened. Eye, open, segments erect, in a small irregular basin. Stem, very stout, ¾ in., nearly always curved, in a very slight depression. Growth, very vigorous; fertility, great. Leaf, large, round pointed, irregularly serrate, sometimes finely, sometimes very coarsely. Origin, found by Meuris, Van Mons' gardener, about 1800, at the Chateau of Perck near Vilvorde, which once belonged to the painter, David Teniers. It was named after Diel, the great German pomologist. A pear which is still very largely grown despite many detractors. As well finished in France it is delicious, but in a cold season it is only fit for stewing.
— U.P. Hedrick, The Pears of New York (1921)BEURRÉ DIEL
- Pom. Mag. 1:119, Pl. 1828. 2. Ibid. 3:131, Pl. 1830. 3. Lindley Guide Orch. Gard. 392. 1831. 4. Kenrick Am. Orch. 189. 1832. 5. Ibid. 156. 1841. 6. Downing Fr. Trees Am. 360, fig. 153. 1845. 7. Gard. Chron. 856. 1845. 8. Hovey Fr. Am. 1:77, Pl. 1851. 9. Am. Pom. Soc. Rpt. 231. 1854. 10. Pom. France 1: No. 7, Pl. 7. 1863. 11. Mas Le Verger 1:137, fig. 67. 1866-73. 12. Leroy Dict. Pom. 1:349, fig. 1867. 13. Downing Fr. Trees Am. 686, fig. 1869. 14. Hogg Fruit Man. 518. 1884. 15. Guide Prat. 234. 1895.
Diel's Butterbirne. 16. Liegel Syst. Anleit. 110. 1825. 17. Lauche Deut. Pom. IX: No. 8, Pl. 8. 1882. 18. Mathieu Nom. Pom. 203. 1889.
Diel. 19. Am. Pom. Soc. Cat. 36. 1883.
The catalogs and text-books supply Beurré Diel with several virtues which Nature denies it as the variety grows in New York. As grown in the eastern United States, the pears are dull and unattractive even at maturity when the pale lemon color is brightest. When the tree is happily situated as to soil and care, the quality of its product is excellent, its fruits being delicious and ranking among the very best, but when illy suited to soil, climate or care, the flesh is coarse, the flavor insipid and astringent, bringing the quality down to second or third rate. The pears keep and ship well. The tree is hardy, uncommonly vigorous and fruitful, but very subject to blight; it is characterized by its long twisting branches which need to be pruned back heavily. The variety is still being planted, but there are better autumn pears.
This variety came from a chance seedling found near Brussels in 1805 by M. Meuris, head gardener for Dr. Van Mons. Being unnamed and of fine quality, Van Mons dedicated it to his German friend, Diel, one of the most distinguished German pomologists. Van Mons sent cions of the variety to the London Horticultural Society in 1817. In 1823, Thomas Andrew Knight sent cions to the Massachusetts Agricultural Society whence it became disseminated generally throughout the United States. The American Pomological Society placed this variety upon its fruit catalog-list in 1854.
Tree medium in size and vigor, spreading, open-topped, slow-growing, hardy, productive; trunk slender, smooth; branches slender, twisting, reddish-brown mingled with grayish scarf-skin, with few lenticels; branchlets with short internodes, dark reddish-brown, smooth, glabrous, with few small, raised lenticels.
Leaf-buds obtuse, free; leaf-scars prominent. Leaves 2½ in. long, 1½ in. wide, oval, thick, leathery; apex abruptly pointed; margin finely serrate; petiole ¾ in. long. Flower-buds large, long, conical, rather plump, free; flowers open early, nearly 1½ in. across, showy, in dense clusters, 7 or 8 buds in a cluster; pedicels 1⅛ in. long, pubescent, greenish.
Fruit ripe in November; large, 3 in. long, 2½ in. wide, uniform in size, obovate-obtuse-pyriform, often irregular and usually with sides unequal; stem 1½ in. long, thick, curved; cavity obtuse, shallow, very narrow, russeted, furrowed and uneven, often lipped; calyx partly open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute; basin shallow, obtuse, furrowed and uneven; skin very thick and granular, somewhat roughened by russet markings and by dots; color lemon-yellow, with a faint pinkish-red blush and markings and flecks of russet; dots many, russet, very conspicuous; flesh yellowish-white, firm, becoming tender and melting, quite granular around the core, very juicy, sweet, aromatic and rich; quality very good.
Core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, plump, often abortive, acute.
— U.P. Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)BEURRE DIEL. Fig. 75. Diel. The catalogs and text-books supply Beurre Diel with several virtues which Nature denies it. As grown in the eastern United States, the pears are dull and unattractive even at maturity when the pale lemon color is brightest. If the tree is happily situated as to soil and care, the quality of its product is excellent, its fruits being delicious and ranking among the very best, but when illy suited to soil, climate or care, the flesh is coarse, the flavor insipid and astringent, bringing the quality down to second or third rate. The pears keep and ship well. The tree is hardy, uncommonly vigorous and fruitful, but very subject to blight; it is characterized by its long twisting branches which need to be pruned back heavily. The variety is still being planted, but there are better autumn pears. This pear was derived from a chance seedling found in 1805 by M. Meuris, Brussels, Belgium.
Tree medium in size and vigor, spreading, open-topped, slow-growing, hardy, productive; trunk slender, smooth; branches slender, twisting, reddish-brown, with few lenticels. Leaves 2½ inches long, 1½ inches wide, oval, thick, leathery; apex abruptly pointed; margin finely serrate; petiole 1½ inches long. Flowers open early, 1¼ inches across, showy, in dense clusters, 7 or 8 buds in a cluster.
Fruit ripe in November; large, 3½ inches long, 2½ inches wide, uniform in size, obovate-obtuse-pyriform, often irregular and usually with sides unequal; stem 1½ inches long, thick, curved; cavity obtuse, shallow, very narrow, russeted, furrowed and uneven, often lipped; calyx partly open, large; lobes separated at the base, broad, acute; basin shallow, obtuse, furrowed and uneven; skin very thick and granular, somewhat roughened by russet markings and dots; color dull greenish-yellow changing to lemon-yellow, with a faint pinkish-red blush and markings and flecks of russet; dots many, russet, very conspicuous; flesh yellowish-white, firm, becoming tender and melting, quite granular around the core, very juicy, sweet, aromatic, and rich; quality very good; core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, usually plump but quite often abortive, acute.
— Central Experimental Farm, Central Experimental Farm, Agassiz BC — Catalogue of Fruit Trees under Test (Bulletin No. 3, 1900) (1900)Planted Spring 1890. Tree a strong grower. Fruit large, obtuse, pyriform. Skin yellow. Flesh yellowish, a little coarse, juicy, sweet and pleasant. Season October and November.
— James Veitch & Sons, Veitch's Fruit Trees (1911) (1911)very large and excellent, the tree is a good flower and very productive. One of the finest pears. Fine for late use Dec. & Jan. Is a good bearer Good wall fruit
— George Bunyard & Co., George Bunyard Catalog of Fruit Trees (1914) (1914)Nov.; ? large; light, medium; pretty golden yellow; dark golden; flesh white, very juicy, buttery and sweet; one of the finest flavored autumn pears. Pretty good prolific; productive. Fine for walls and standards.