Beurré Clairgeau
PearOrigin & History
Beurré Clairgeau originated as a chance seedling with Pierre Clairgeau of Nantes, France. Hedrick dates the original tree to about 1830, while Hovey states the parent tree was raised in 1835 or 1836 and first bore fruit in 1846 or 1847. In 1848, M. Clairgeau first exhibited fruit before the Horticultural Society of Nantes, and its perfect form, beautiful exterior, and fine quality at once established its reputation. According to Hovey, a subscription was immediately opened by several cultivators to purchase the entire stock, but as the requisite number of two hundred subscribers could not be obtained, the trees remained in the hands of the originator. In 1850, M. de Jonghe and other nurserymen completed the subscription and took the entire stock — in all about three hundred trees on the quince. These, together with the parent tree, were removed to Brussels in November 1850. They produced fruit the following year, enabling the purchasers to again test its quality. It was not until 1852 that the trees were offered for sale. As Hedrick notes, it thus happened that a French pear was first distributed by Belgian growers. Desportes adds that the variety was put in trade by the care of the Horticultural Society of Nantes. The variety was introduced in America about 1854. The American Pomological Society placed it upon its list of recommended fruits in 1860.
Tree
The tree is vigorous, unusually upright and erect, forming a beautiful pyramid. Hovey describes it as branching at a very acute angle, making rather stout wood, with annual shoots of medium length, more resembling the Buffum than any other variety but with larger, richer, and more ornamental foliage. Hedrick likewise rates it second only to Buffum in vigor, health, and productiveness, and nearly as handsome as an ornamental, adding that it is medium in size, dense, slow-growing, hardy, productive, and a regular bearer. Young wood is reddish brown (Downing, Hovey). Elliott describes the wood as light yellow, in contrast to the reddish-brown described by all other sources.
Trunk and branches (Hedrick): Trunk slender, shaggy. Branches smooth, slightly zigzag, ash-gray almost completely overspreading reddish-brown, with many lenticels. Branchlets thick, short, with short internodes, greenish-brown, smooth, glabrous, with slightly raised lenticels.
Buds (Hovey): Large, long, sharply pointed, diverging, with prominent shoulders. Flower-buds medium size, oval, very sharply pointed. Buds (Hedrick): Leaf-buds conical, pointed, appressed. Flower-buds medium to long, conical, pointed.
Leaves (Hedrick): Very numerous, 3 inches long, 2 inches wide, broadly oval, leathery; apex abruptly pointed; margin glandless, finely serrate; petiole 2 inches long, glabrous; stipules rudimentary or lacking. Leaves (Hovey): Large, roundish ovate, broadest about the middle, rather thick, deep green, glossy, nearly flat, and coarsely and very slightly serrated; petioles long, about one and a half inches in length, little tinged with red, and moderately stout.
Flowers (Hedrick): One and a half inches across, showy, in dense clusters, averaging seven buds to a cluster; pedicels three-quarters of an inch long, thick, pubescent, greenish. Flowers (Hovey): Medium size; petals roundish ovate, neatly cupped; clusters compact.
Bearing habit: Bears remarkably young; Hovey notes that scions inserted in moderately strong trees produced fruit the following year. All sources agree the tree is very productive.
Rootstock compatibility: Hedrick states it does equally well on quince or pear stock, though the Europeans maintain the product is better on the dwarfing stock; on either stock the trees bear young and annually. Hovey notes it appears to succeed well upon the quince. However, Elliott states it does not succeed on quince, recommending it as an orchard variety on the pear root — a direct contradiction of the other sources.
Fruit
Size
Large. Hovey gives dimensions of about four inches long and three inches in diameter. Hedrick gives three and a half inches long and two and a half inches wide, uniform in size. Hedrick notes the pears are heavy and often drop before maturity, and the trees should not be set in windswept situations.
Form
Sources vary somewhat in describing the shape. Hedrick: roundish-acute-pyriform, with a long tapering neck, symmetrical, uniform in shape. Downing: pyriform, but with unequal sides. Hovey: oblong or obtuse pyramidal, large at the crown, slightly contracted in the middle, obtuse at the stem, with a somewhat uneven surface. Elliott: oblong obovate pyriform. Desportes: irregularly turbinated. The descriptions from Downing and Hovey suggesting asymmetry or unevenness conflict with Hedrick's "symmetrical, uniform in shape."
Stem
Short, stout, and fleshy. Hovey: about half an inch long, very stout, fleshy at the base, obliquely inserted without any cavity, but surrounded by a few uneven projections. Hedrick: three-quarters of an inch long, short, very thick and fleshy. Downing: short, stout, and fleshy, inserted by a lip at an inclination almost without depression; when the lip is absent the cavity is uneven.
Cavity
Hedrick: obtuse, very shallow and narrow, fleshy around the base of the stem, russeted, lipped. Downing: almost without depression; when the lip is absent the cavity is uneven. Hovey describes the stem as inserted without any cavity, surrounded by a few uneven projections.
Calyx
Open. Hedrick: large; lobes separated at the base, long, broad, acute or acuminate. Downing: segments stiff. Hovey: eye small, open; segments of the calyx short, stiff, pointed, complete. Elliott: small, open.
Basin
Shallow. Hedrick: narrow, obtuse, furrowed, often compressed. Downing: shallow, furrowed. Hovey: very shallow, somewhat ribbed, only slightly depressed.
Skin
Downing: warm yellow, inclining to fawn, shaded with orange and crimson, thickly covered with russet dots, and sometimes sprinkled with russet. Hedrick: thick and granular, tough, smooth, glossy; color yellow with bright red blush; dots many, small, russet, conspicuous. In his general remarks, Hedrick describes the ground color as rich yellow at maturity with a bright crimson cheek. Hovey: slightly rough, of a clear cinnamon russet, with numerous darker colored specks, acquiring at maturity a deep reddish tint on the sunny side. Elliott: mostly russet, reddish in sun. Desportes: yellow greenish, with dark spots.
Flesh & Flavor
All sources agree the flesh is juicy and buttery or melting, but assessments of quality differ significantly between earlier and later sources.
Downing: yellowish, buttery, juicy, somewhat granular, with a sugary, perfumed, vinous flavor. Rated "Good."
Hedrick: white, quite granular, firm at first but becoming at maturity tender and melting, buttery, very juicy, sweet, aromatic, with a rich, vinous flavor. Quality rated as variable, good to best. In his general description, Hedrick is more critical: the "deceptive cheek of the Clairgeau" is proverbial in pear-growing, the handsome coat covering rather coarse, granular flesh which is sometimes very good but more often commonplace. The flesh surrounding the core often rots or softens prematurely.
Hovey: yellowish, rather coarse, melting and juicy. Flavor saccharine, sprightly, perfumed and delicious.
Elliott: yellowish, rather coarse, juicy, vinous. Rated "very good."
Desportes: melting, buttery, juicy; resembles the Gray Doyenné. Rated first-rate quality.
Core & Seeds
Hedrick: core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, plump, acute. Hovey: core medium size; seeds small, ovate, pointed. The two sources disagree on both core size and seed size.
Season
Late October through November, with some keeping ability. Downing gives the widest range: October to January. Hovey states it ripens in November and keeps nearly a month. Hedrick gives late October and November. Desportes and Elliott both give October and November.
Uses
Hedrick considers the fruit more suitable for cookery than dessert, noting that despite the demerits of the fruit, the variety is well worth planting in commercial orchards for late markets. Downing likewise emphasizes that the size, early bearing, productiveness, and beauty of this pear render it a profitable market sort. Elliott calls it probably one of the most valuable as a large-sized pear and desirable as an orchard variety on the pear root. Hovey, writing earlier when the variety was newer, is more enthusiastic, calling it likely to prove one of the most popular pears, second only to the Bartlett, Seckel, and a few others, possessing all the qualities that constitute a fine pear.
Subtypes/Variants
Not described in source.
Other
Hedrick provides an extensive bibliography of references to this variety, citing publications from 1851 through 1907, including French, Belgian, German, British, and American sources.
Book Sources
Described in 5 period pomological works
Nursery Catalog Sources
Found in 53 catalogs (1864–1921) from Alabama, California, England, Florida, Illinois, Missouri, Oregon, Washington
- St. Helena Nursery , Howell's Prairie, Marion County , Oregon — 1864
- Hutchison Nursery , James Hutchison, Oakland , California — 1881
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1884
- Fancher Creek Nursery , Fresno , California — 1886
- Huntsville Wholesale Nurseries (Jessie S. Moss , Proprietor; W.F. Heikes, Manager), Huntsville , Alabama — 1886
- W.R. Strong & Co. , Capital and Orange Hill Nurseries (Robert Williamson, prop.), Sacramento , California — 1886
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1888
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1889
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1890
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1891
- Missouri Nursery Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1891
- Puyallup & Yakima Nurseries , Puyallup, Washington (Lock Box 191) and North Yakima , Washington — 1892
- Glen St. Mary Nurseries (G.L. Taber , Proprietor), Glen St. Mary , Florida — 1893
- Milwaukie-Canby Nurseries , Canby, OR (and Milwaukie, OR) — 1893
- Oregon Wholesale Nurseries , Salem , Oregon — 1893
- Multnomah Nurseries , Russellville , Oregon — 1894
- The Vineland Nurseries (Kelsey & Co. , Proprietors), St. Joseph, Missouri (Office: 13th and Atchison Sts., 2 Blocks East of the Citizens St. Car Line) — 1894
- Woodburn Nurseries , Woodburn, Marion Co. , Oregon — 1894
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1895
- Felix Gillet , Barren Hill Nursery, Nevada City , California — 1897
- Kelway & Son , Langport, Somerset , England — 1897
- Stark Bros. Nurseries & Orchards Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1898
- Alabama Nursery Co. , Huntsville , Alabama — 1900
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1900
- Washington Nursery Co. , Toppenish , Washington — 1901
- S.L. Watkins , Grizzly Flats, El Dorado County , California — 1901
- Pacific Nursery Company (W. O. Hudson & A. D. Hudson) , Tangent , Oregon — 1903
- Russellville Nursery Co. , Russellville, OR (three miles east of Portland, one mile from Montavilla car line) — 1903
- Phoenix Nursery Company (W. E. Rossney , President; Sidney Tuttle, Vice-President), Bloomington , Illinois — 1904
- The Dalles Nurseries , The Dalles , Oregon — 1906
- Stark Bros. Nurseries & Orchards Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1906
- J.B. Pilkington , Portland , Oregon — 1907
- Russellville Nursery Co. , Montavilla Station, Portland, OR (three miles east of Portland, one mile from Montavilla car line) — 1907
- Carlton Nursery Co. , Carlton , Oregon — 1909
- Washington Nursery Company , Toppenish , Washington — 1909
- C.F. Lansing , Salem , Oregon — 1910
- Stark Bros. Nurseries & Orchards Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1910
- Stark Bros. Nurseries & Orchards Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1911
- James Veitch & Sons , Ltd., Royal Exotic Nursery, Chelsea, London (also Coombe Wood, Langley, and Feltham) , England — 1911
- Ballygreen Nurseries , Hanford , Washington — 1912
- Pacific Nursery Company , Portland , Oregon — 1912
- Stark Bros. Nurseries & Orchards Co. , Louisiana , Missouri — 1912
- Vineland Nurseries Company , Clarkston , Washington — 1912
- Washington Nursery Company , Toppenish , Washington — 1912
- J. B. Pilkington , Nurseryman, Portland, OR (nurseries near Newberg, forty miles from Portland) — 1913
- Van Holderbeke Nursery Co. , Incorporated, Spokane, Washington (nurseries at Otis Orchards WA, Pasadena WA, Kennewick WA) — 1913
- Thomas Rivers & Son , Sawbridgeworth, Hertfordshire , England — 1913
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1914
- Union Nurseries , J.B. Weaver & Sons, Union , Oregon — 1915
- George Bunyard & Co. , Royal Nurseries, Maidstone, Kent , England — 1917
- Fancher Creek Nurseries , George C. Roeding, Fresno , California — 1918
- Oregon Nursery Co. , Orenco , Oregon — 1920
- Benedict Nursery Co. , Portland , Oregon — 1921
View original book sources (5)
— B. Desportes, The Horticulturist (1856)Beurre Clairgeau of Nantes.
III. Beurre Clairgeau, (of Nantes.)—A very large fruit, irregularly turbinated; skin—yellow greenish, with dark spots; flesh—melting, buttery, juicy; resembles the Gray Doyenne; ripens in October and November. A vigorous tree; very productive, and forming fine pyramids. It is a handsome pear of first rate quality, raised from seed by Mr. Clairgeau, at Nantes, (France,) and put in trade by the care of the Horticultural Society of this city. Yours very respectfully, Andre Le Roy. Angers, France, 1st Sept., 1851.
— A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)Beurré Clairgeau.
Clairgeau. Clairgeau de Nantes.
Raised by Pierre Clairgeau, of Nantes, France. Tree very vigorous, forming a beautiful pyramid. Young wood reddish brown, very productive.
The size, early bearing, productiveness, and beauty of this Pear render it a profitable market sort.
Fruit large, pyriform, but with unequal sides. Skin warm yellow, inclining to fawn, shaded with orange and crimson, thickly covered with russet dots, and sometimes sprinkled with russet. Stalk short, stout, and fleshy, inserted by a lip at an inclination almost without depression; when the lip is absent the cavity is uneven. Calyx open. Segments stiff, in a shallow furrowed basin. Flesh yellowish, buttery, juicy, somewhat granular, with a sugary, perfumed, vinous flavor. Good. October to January.
— U.P. Hedrick, The Pears of New York (1921)BEURRÉ CLAIRGEAU
- Hovey Fr. Am. 2:73, Pl. 1851. 2. Ann. Pom. Belge 2:103, Pl. 1854. 3. Gard. Chron. 805. 1854. 4. Am. Pom. Soc. Rpt. 337. 1860. 5. Pom. France 1: No. 11, Pl. 11. 1863. 6. Mas Le Verger 1:39, fig. 26. 1866-73. 7. Jour. Hort. N. S. 12:211. 1867. 8. Leroy Dict. Pom. 1:335, fig. 1867. 9. Downing Fr. Trees Am. 678. 1869. 10. Gard. Chron. 1271. 1873. 11. Hogg Fruit Man. 517. 1884.
Clairgeau's Butterbirne. 12. Dochnahl Führ. Obstkunde 2:127. 1856. 13. Lauche Deut. Pom. II: No. 7, Pl. 7. 1882. 14. Deut. Obstsorten 3: Pt. 9, Pl. 1907.
Clairgeau. 15. Am. Pom. Soc. Cat. 36. 1883.
Beurré Clairgeau is one of the mainstays in American pear-growing, and is an especially valuable variety in New York. It maintains its place among standard varieties chiefly because of splendid tree-characters, as the fruits, while handsome, are not of the best quality. The tree is second only to that of Buffum in vigor, health, and productiveness, and is nearly as handsome as an ornamental. It does equally well on quince or pear stock, although the Europeans maintain that the product is better on the dwarfing stock. On either stock, the trees bear young and annually. The fruits are large, smooth, symmetrical, and uniform in shape, with a handsome ground color of rich yellow at maturity and a bright crimson cheek. But here praises end, for the "deceptive cheek of the Clairgeau" is proverbial in pear-growing, the handsome coat covering rather coarse, granular flesh which is sometimes very good but more often commonplace. The core is very large, and the flesh surrounding it often rots or softens prematurely. The fruit is more suitable for cookery than dessert. The pears are heavy and often drop before maturity, and the trees should not be set in windswept situations. Despite these demerits of the fruits, the variety is well worth planting in commercial orchards for late markets.
The original tree of Beurré Clairgeau appears to have grown by chance about 1830 with Pierre Clairgeau, Nantes, France. M. Clairgeau's first account of it was given in 1848 when he exhibited fruit. The reputation of the variety seems to have been at once established, for J. de Jonghe and others combined and purchased the stock of about 300 trees grafted on quince. Together with the parent tree, these were the same year removed to Brussels, and in 1852 the pear was placed on the market. Thus it happened that a French pear was first distributed by Belgian growers. The variety was introduced in America about 1854. The American Pomological Society placed it upon its list of recommended fruits in 1860.
Tree medium in size, vigorous, unusually upright, dense, slow-growing, hardy, productive, a regular bearer; trunk slender, shaggy; branches smooth, slightly zigzag, ash-gray almost completely overspreading reddish-brown, with many lenticels; branchlets thick, short, with short internodes, greenish-brown, smooth, glabrous, with slightly raised lenticels.
Leaf-buds conical, pointed, appressed; leaves very numerous, 3 in. long, 2 in. wide, broadly oval, leathery; apex abruptly pointed; margin glandless, finely serrate; petiole 2 in. long, glabrous; stipules rudimentary or lacking. Flower-buds medium to long, conical, pointed; flowers 1½ in. across, showy, in dense clusters, averaging 7 buds to a cluster; pedicels ¾ in. long, thick, pubescent, greenish.
Fruit in season, late October and November; large, 3½ in. long, 2½ in. wide, uniform in size, roundish-acute-pyriform, with a long, tapering neck, symmetrical, uniform in shape; stem ¾ in. long, short, very thick and fleshy; cavity obtuse, very shallow and narrow, fleshy around the base of the stem, russeted, lipped; calyx open, large; lobes separated at the base, long, broad, acute or acuminate; basin shallow, narrow, obtuse, furrowed, often compressed; skin thick and granular, tough, smooth, glossy; color yellow, with bright red blush; dots many, small, russet, conspicuous; flesh white, quite granular, firm at first but becoming at maturity tender and melting, buttery, very juicy, sweet, aromatic, with a rich, vinous flavor; quality variable, good to best. Core large, closed, with clasping core-lines; calyx-tube short, wide, conical; seeds large, wide, long, plump, acute.
— C.M. Hovey, The Fruits of America (1852)THE BEURRÉ CLAIRGEAU PEAR.
Beurré Clairgeau. Album de Pomologie, vol. iv. p. 145.
No pear of recent introduction has attracted the attention of pomologists more than the Beurre Clairgeau. Remarkably handsome in its appearance, very large in size, excellent in quality, a vigorous, erect, and beautiful growing tree, hardy, early, and an abundant bearer, it possesses all the qualities that constitute a fine pear. Preceded with a high reputation, it is gratifying to find that it has fully maintained its character, and is likely to prove one of the most popular pears, second only to the Bartlett, Seckel, and a few others.
The Beurre Clairgeau is a French variety, and was originated by Peter Clairgeau of Nantes. The parent tree was raised in 1835 or '36, and first bore fruit in 1846 or '47. In 1848, the fruit was first exhibited before the Horticultural Society of Nantes, and its perfect form, beautiful exterior, and fine quality, at once established its reputation. A subscription was immediately opened by several cultivators to purchase the entire stock; but as the requisite number (two hundred) could not be obtained, the trees remained in the hands of the originator. In 1850, however, M. de Jonghe and other nurserymen completed the subscription and took the entire stock, in all about three hundred trees on the quince. These, with the parent tree, were removed to Brussels in November, 1850. They produced fruit the following year, and enabled the purchasers to again test its quality, which was found to be excellent. But it was not till 1852, when the trees had borne another crop, that they were offered for sale.
The Beurre Clairgeau is a very upright and erect growing tree, more resembling the Buffum than any other variety; but the foliage is larger, richer and more ornamental. It bears remarkably young, scions inserted in moderately strong trees producing fruit the following year. It appears to succeed well upon the quince.
Tree. — Moderately vigorous, very upright and erect, branching at a very acute angle, and making rather stout wood; annual shoots of medium length.
Wood. — Reddish brown, dotted with rather large whitish specks, stout and short-jointed; old wood, brownish olive; buds, large, long, sharply pointed, diverging, with prominent shoulders: Flower-buds, medium size, oval, very sharply pointed.
Leaves. — Large, roundish ovate, broadest about the middle, rather thick, deep green, glossy, nearly flat, and coarsely and very slightly serrated; petioles, long, about one and a half inches in length, little tinged with red, and moderately stout.
Flowers. — Medium size; petals, roundish ovate, neatly cupped; clusters, compact.
Fruit. — Very large, about four inches long, and three inches in diameter: Form, oblong, or obtuse pyramidal, large at the crown, slightly contracted in the middle, obtuse at the stem, with a somewhat uneven surface: Skin, slightly rough, of a clear cinnamon russet, with numerous darker colored specks, acquiring, at maturity, a deep reddish tint on the sunny side: Stem, short, about half an inch long, very stout, fleshy at the base, obliquely inserted without any cavity, but surrounded by a few uneven projections: Eye, small, open, and but slightly depressed in a very shallow basin, somewhat ribbed; segments of the calyx, short, stiff, pointed, complete: Flesh, yellowish, rather coarse, melting and juicy: Flavor, saccharine, sprightly, perfumed and delicious: Core, medium size: Seeds, small, ovate, pointed.
Ripe in November, and keeps nearly a month.
— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)Beurre Clairgeau.
Foreign. Tree, vigorous, light yellow wood. Fruit, large, oblong obovate pyriform: color, mostly russet, reddish in sun: stem, short, stout; calyx, small, open; flesh, yellowish, rather coarse, juicy, vinous ; "very good." October, November. This will probably prove one of the most valuable, as a large-sized pear, and desirable as an orchard variety, on the pear root. Growing strong, and bearing very young : does not succeed on Quince.