← All varieties

Green Sweet

Apple

Green Sweet

Origin / History

An old variety of uncertain origin, probably originating more than a century ago in New England (Hedrick). It was already well known and much cultivated in Northeastern Massachusetts in the first half of the nineteenth century, and has long been highly esteemed in Central and Western New York (Beach). Thomas attributes it to Massachusetts. The Sweet Greening of Thacher (1822) or Green Sweeting of Kenrick (1832) is said to be distinct from this variety (Beach). Beach further notes that a fall apple has been introduced from Russia under the name Green Sweet, treated as a distinct variety in the succeeding volume of his work.

[NOTE: Source text may be incorrect — Hansen (1902), describing specimens received as "Green Sweeting No. 169" from F. J. Peterson of Waconia, gives the origin as Russia and describes a fall-ripening fruit with dull red stripes and splashes and mild subacid-sweet flesh; per Beach, this is the distinct Russian Green Sweet, not the New England variety. Hansen's details are reproduced below under "Other" for completeness.]

Tree

Vigorous (Warder, Downing, Beach, Hedrick), or moderately vigorous (Beach); hardy (Elliott); productive (Warder, Downing, Elliott), a good reliable cropper bearing biennially and yielding so abundantly that the fruit commonly averages below medium or rather small, but is perfect, smooth, bright, regular and uniform in size and shape with little loss from drops and culls (Beach). Medium or sometimes large (Beach), large (Hedrick). Form upright spreading (Downing), erect or roundish, rather compact (Beach), upright and rather compact (Beach in summary), compact, erect or round-topped (Hedrick), half-spreading (Elliott). Branches moderately stout (Beach) or stout (Hedrick); young branches dark green (Beach, Hedrick); shoots rather slender (Elliott). Twigs short, straight, stout; internodes short (Beach). Bark very dark brown, mingled with reddish-brown, lightly streaked with scarf-skin; pubescent near tips (Beach). Lenticels numerous, medium, oblong, slightly raised, rather conspicuous (Beach). Buds large, plump, broad, obtuse, free, slightly pubescent (Beach). The tree is unique in its upright, compact growth and in bearing fruit close to the branches on short laterals and spurs (Beach, Hedrick); it may be set more closely in the orchard than either Baldwin or Rhode Island Greening because it does not grow so large and is decidedly more upright (Beach). Wants deep, rich, strong soil; fruit always fair (Elliott). Not much planted in the West (Warder).

Fruit

Size

Rather small (Warder); medium (Downing, Budd-Hansen, Lowther); medium or often below medium, sometimes large (Beach); medium, sometimes large (Hedrick); medium to large (Elliott); large or medium (Thomas). Fruit commonly averages below medium or rather small but is perfect, smooth, bright, regular and uniform in size and shape (Beach).

Form

Regular and usually flat, though sometimes conical (Warder); roundish oblate, somewhat conic (Downing, Budd-Hansen); roundish oblate (Lowther); ovate to roundish inclined to conic, sometimes obscurely ribbed; pretty regular and uniform in size (Beach); ovate to round-conic, sometimes obscurely ribbed, regular and uniform in size (Hedrick); roundish (Elliott); nearly round, slightly approaching ovate-conical, regular (Thomas).

Stem

Long and stout (Warder); of medium length (Downing); medium to long, stout (Budd-Hansen); medium to rather long, slender to moderately thick (Beach); long, slender (Hedrick); varying (Elliott); about an inch long, moderately thick (Thomas).

Cavity

Wide, regular and brown (Warder); rather deep, covered with russet (Downing); wide, regular, rather deep, covered with russet (Budd-Hansen); somewhat furrowed, deep, acuminate, moderately broad, smooth or with some radiating russet rays (Beach); furrowed, deep, acuminate, broad, smooth or open (Hedrick); narrow, russeted (Elliott); rather small and narrow, round, acuminate (Thomas).

Calyx

Large, closed (Warder); medium to rather large, closed or somewhat open; lobes rather leafy, long, acute (Beach); lobes leafy, long, acute (Hedrick); above medium size for the fruit, closed (Elliott). Calyx tube wide, cone-shape; stamens median (Beach, Hedrick).

Basin

Rather shallow and wavy (Warder); shallow and abrupt, somewhat furrowed (Downing); shallow, abrupt, somewhat wavy and furrowed (Budd-Hansen); variable, usually medium in width and depth, abrupt, slightly wrinkled and more or less obscurely furrowed (Beach); variable, medium in width and depth, abrupt, wrinkled and more or less obscurely furrowed (Hedrick); medium, slightly furrowed (Elliott); small, slightly furrowed (Thomas).

Skin

Surface smooth, green (Warder); skin green, sometimes becoming a little yellow at maturity (Downing, Budd-Hansen); grass-green eventually becoming pretty yellow with a thin brownish-red blush in highly colored specimens; prevailing color green (Beach); green, becoming yellow, with a thin brownish-red blush; prevailing color green (Hedrick); dull greenish white or yellow (Elliott); surface green (Thomas); greenish yellow (Lowther).

Dots

Whitish, with green bases (Warder); covered with greenish or light russet dots (Downing); whitish or light russet with green bases (Budd-Hansen); green or with fine russet point, often submerged and whitish (Beach, Hedrick); greenish white, or sometimes pale russet (Elliott); greenish white (Thomas).

Flesh and Flavor

Greenish-white, breaking, tender, juicy and fine grained; very sweet, and valued for baking and market; those who do not admire sweet apples would hardly consider it second rate (Warder). Whitish, tender, juicy, sweet, pleasant; good (Downing). Whitish, tender, juicy, very sweet, pleasant, good (Budd-Hansen). Greenish-white, tender, fine-grained, juicy, very sweet, good (Beach, Hedrick). Greenish white, tender, juicy, and quite sweet (Elliott). Greenish white, with a very sweet, spicy, good flavor (Thomas). A desirable late keeping apple excellent for either dessert or culinary use; holds its flavor and remains crisp, brittle and juicy till spring; one of the best late keeping sweet apples in cultivation in New York (Beach). From apple harvest to apple blossoming, a delicious sweet apple either for dessert or culinary uses (Hedrick). Quality good (Lowther).

Core and Seeds

Core closed, regular, meeting the eye, containing numerous angular, acuminate brown seeds (Warder); core closed, regular, meeting; seeds many, angular, long-pointed (Budd-Hansen); core rather large, abaxile, open; core lines somewhat clasping or nearly meeting; carpels roundish ovate; seeds numerous, medium or below, rather narrow, acute (Beach); core large, abaxile, open; core-lines clasping or meeting; carpels round-ovate; seeds numerous, small, narrow, acute (Hedrick); core medium, round; seeds ovate (Elliott).

Season

December to February or March (Warder); December to March (Downing, Budd-Hansen, Elliott); December to April or May (Beach, Hedrick); winter (Lowther). Often kept in common cellar storage till April or May (Beach). A long keeper (Thomas). The fruits remain crisp and juicy until spring (Hedrick).

Uses

Dessert and culinary use (Beach, Hedrick); valued for baking and market (Warder); both kitchen and market (Lowther); valuable for cooking and for stock (Elliott). Grown with profit for selling in local markets wherever it is well known, but does not sell so readily in the general market because it is not large and not well known and because the trade demands chiefly red, subacid apples (Beach). Apples are easily picked because the habit of the tree is upright and rather compact and it usually bears its fruit close to the branches or on short laterals or spurs (Beach).

Subtypes / Variants

Grown in Indiana, it is large, has a brownish cheek, and matures in October and November (Elliott).

Other

Lowther's geographic reporting (1914): Northern Division, 3 reporting stations (also reported in another division); Central Division, 2 reporting stations (also reported in another division); Southern Division, not reported.

Hansen's "Green Sweet (Green Sweeting No. 169)" — almost certainly the distinct Russian fall apple flagged by Beach — is reproduced here for completeness: "Origin, Russia. Specimens from F. J. Peterson, of Waconia, who writes: 'A good hardy tree, and rather low open top, and a very shy bearer.' — Fruit medium, very regular, roundish conical; surface greenish yellow, mostly thinly covered with dull red stripes and splashes; dots obscure, few, white; cavity regular, obtuse, trace of stellate russet; stem long; basin very shallow (nearly flat), slightly wrinkled; calyx half open or open, segments flat convergent. Core open, sessile; cells nearly entire, abaxile, large, roomy; tube funnel-shaped; stamens median; seeds numerous, small, sharp, pointed; flesh mild subacid, sweet. Fall."

Book Sources

Described in 9 period pomological works

USDA Nomenclature (1905)

From W.H. Ragan, Nomenclature of the Apple, USDA Bulletin No. 56

May be Victuals and Drink.

Nursery Catalog Sources

Found in 3 catalogs (1894–1901) from Illinois, Oregon

View original book sources (9)

Green Sweet.

HONEY GREENING.

Tree vigorous and productive in most situations where cultivated, but is not much planted in the West.

Fruit rather small, regular, and usually flat, though sometimes conical; Surface smooth, green; Dots whitish, with green bases.

Basin rather shallow and wavy; Eye large, closed.

Cavity wide, regular and brown; Stem long and stout.

Core closed, regular, meeting the eye, containing numerous angular, acuminate brown seeds; Flesh greenish-white, breaking, tender, juicy and fine grained; very sweet, and valued for baking and market; those who do not admire sweet apples would hardly consider it second rate.

Season from December to February, or March.

— John A. Warder, American Pomology: Apples (1867)

Green Sweet.

Honey Greening.

Tree vigorous, upright spreading, and productive.

Fruit medium, roundish oblate, somewhat conic. Skin green, sometimes becoming a little yellow at maturity, covered with greenish or light russet dots. Stalk of medium length. Cavity rather deep, covered with russet. Basin shallow and abrupt, somewhat furrowed. Flesh whitish, tender, juicy, sweet, pleasant. Good. December to March.

A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)

GREEN SWEET.

References. 1. Manning, 1838:63. 2. Manning, Mag. Hort., 7:45. 1841. 3. Thomas, 1849:162. 4. Emmons, Nat. Hist. N. Y., 3:90. 1851. 5. Horticulturist, 9:192. 1854. 6. Hooper, 1857:45. 7. Downing, 1857:81. 8. Elliott, 1858:83. fig. 9. Mag. Hort., 27:152. 1861. 10. Am. Pom. Soc. Cat., 1862. 11. Warder, 1867:385. 12. Barry, 1883:347. 13. Bailey, An. Hort., 1892:240. 14. Budd-Hansen, 1903:95. 15. Powell and Fulton, U. S. B. P. I. Bul., 48:42. 1903.

Synonyms. Green Sweet (6). Green Sweeting (5). Green Sweeting (4). Honey Greening (6). Honey Greening (7, 8, 11, 12).

A desirable late keeping apple excellent for either dessert or culinary use. It holds its flavor and remains crisp, brittle and juicy till spring. Often it is kept in common cellar storage till April or May. It is undoubtedly one of the best late keeping sweet apples in cultivation in this state. It is grown with profit for selling in local markets wherever it is well known, but it does not sell so readily in the general market because it is not large and not well known and because the trade demands chiefly red, subacid apples. The tree is a good reliable cropper, bears biennially and yields so abundantly that the fruit commonly averages below medium or rather small, but it is perfect, smooth, bright, regular and uniform in size and shape with little loss from drops and culls. The apples are easily picked because the habit of the tree is upright and rather compact and it usually bears its fruit close to the branches or on short laterals or spurs. Green Sweet may be set more closely in the orchard than either Baldwin or Rhode Island Greening because it does not grow so large as either of these varieties and is decidedly more upright in habit.

The Sweet Greening of Thacher¹ or Green Sweeting of Kenrick² is said to be distinct from this variety.

A fall apple has been introduced from Russia under the name Green Sweet. This will be noticed in the succeeding volume.

Historical. An old variety of uncertain origin. It was already well known and much cultivated in Northeastern Massachusetts in the first half of the last century (1). It has long been highly esteemed in Central and Western New York (3, 4, 5, 9).

Tree.

Tree medium or sometimes large, vigorous or moderately vigorous; branches moderately stout; young branches dark green. Form erect or roundish, rather compact. Twigs short, straight, stout; internodes short. Bark very dark brown, mingled with reddish-brown, lightly streaked with scarf-skin; pubescent near tips. Lenticels numerous, medium, oblong, slightly raised, rather conspicuous. Buds large, plump, broad, obtuse, free, slightly pubescent.

Fruit.

Fruit medium or often below medium, sometimes large. Form ovate to roundish inclined to conic, sometimes obscurely ribbed; pretty regular and uniform in size. Stem medium to rather long, slender to moderately thick. Cavity somewhat furrowed, deep, acuminate, moderately broad, smooth or with some radiating russet rays. Calyx medium to rather large, closed or somewhat open; lobes rather leafy, long, acute. Basin variable, usually medium in width and depth, abrupt, slightly wrinkled and more or less obscurely furrowed.

Skin grass-green eventually becoming pretty yellow with a thin brownish-red blush in highly colored specimens. Dots green or with fine russet point, often submerged and whitish. Prevailing color green.

Calyx tube wide, cone-shape. Stamens median.

Core rather large, abaxile, open; core lines somewhat clasping or nearly meeting. Carpels roundish ovate. Seeds numerous, medium or below, rather narrow, acute.

Flesh greenish-white, tender, fine-grained, juicy, very sweet, good.

Season December to April or May.

¹Thacher, 1822:138. ²Kenrick, 1832:46.

S.A. Beach, The Apples of New York, Vol. 1 (1905)

Green Sweet. Size: medium. Form: roundish (oblate). Color: greenish yellow. Quality: good. Use: both kitchen and market. Season: winter. Northern Division: 3 reporting stations (also reported in another division). Central Division: 2 reporting stations (also reported in another division). Southern Division: not reported.

— Granville Lowther (ed.), Encyclopedia of Practical Horticulture (1914)

Green Sweet. Honey Greening.

Tree, hardy; productive, half spreading; shoots rather slender; fruit valuable for cooking and for stock; wants deep, rich, strong soil; fruit always fair.

Fruit, medium to large; form, roundish; color, dull greenish white or yellow, with greenish white, or sometimes pale russet dots; stem, varying; cavity, narrow, russeted; calyx, above medium size for the fruit, closed; basin, medium, slightly furrowed; flesh, greenish white, tender, juicy, and quite sweet; core, medium, round; seeds, ovate. December to March. Grown in Indiana, it is large, has a brownish cheek, and matures in October and November.

— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)

Green Sweet (Green Sweeting No. 169)-Origin, Russia. Specimens from F. J. Peterson, of Waconia, who writes: "A good hardy tree, and rather low open top, and a very shy bearer."-Fruit medium, very regular, roundish conical; surface greenish yellow, mostly thinly covered with dull red stripes and splashes; dots obscure, few, white; cavity regular, obtuse, trace of stellate russet; stem long; basin very shallow (nearly flat), slightly wrinkled; calyx half open or open, segments flat convergent. Core open, sessile; cells nearly entire, abaxile, large, roomy; tube funnel-shaped; stamens median; seeds numerous, small, sharp, pointed; flesh mild subacid, sweet. Fall.

— N.E. Hansen, A Study of Northwestern Apples (1902)

Green Sweet.* Large or medium, nearly round, slightly approaching ovate-conical, regular; surface green, with greenish white dots; stalk about an inch long, moderately thick, cavity rather small and narrow, round, acuminate; basin small, slightly furrowed; flesh greenish white, with a very sweet, spicy, good flavor. Fair, productive, and a long keeper. Fig. 407. Massachusetts.

— John J. Thomas, The American Fruit Culturist (1903)

Green Sweet. — Fruit medium, roundish oblate, somewhat conic; surface green, sometimes becoming a little yellow at maturity; dots whitish or light russet with green bases; cavity wide, regular, rather deep, covered with russet; stem medium to long, stout; basin shallow, abrupt, somewhat wavy and furrowed. Core closed, regular, meeting; seeds many, angular, long-pointed; flesh whitish, tender, juicy, very sweet, pleasant, good. December to March.

— J.L. Budd & N.E. Hansen, American Horticultural Manual, Part II: Systematic Pomology (1914)

GREEN SWEET. Green Sweeting. Honey Sweeting.

The fruits of this excellent variety remain crisp and juicy until spring: from apple harvest to apple blossoming, it is a delicious sweet apple either for dessert or culinary uses. The fruits run small, with the result that there is usually much loss from culls, as there is also from dropping. The tree is unique in its upright, compact growth, and in bearing fruit close to the branches on short laterals and spurs. The variety probably originated more than a century ago in New England, where it is still chiefly grown.

Tree large, vigorous, compact, erect or round-topped; branches stout, young branches dark green. Fruit medium, sometimes large, ovate to round-conic, sometimes obscurely ribbed, regular and uniform in size; stem long, slender; cavity furrowed, deep, acuminate, broad, smooth or open; lobes leafy, long, acute; basin variable, medium in width and depth, abrupt, wrinkled and more or less obscurely furrowed; skin green, becoming yellow, with a thin brownish-red blush; dots green or with fine russet point, often submerged and white; prevailing color green; calyx-tube wide, cone-shape; stamens median; core large, abaxile, open; core-lines clasping or meeting; carpels round-ovate; seeds numerous, small, narrow, acute; flesh greenish-white, tender, fine-grained, juicy, very sweet; good; December to April or May.

U.P. Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)
Green Sweeting Green Sweeting No. 169 Honey Greening Honey Sweeting Pelham Sweet Honey Greening Honey Sweet Repka Malenka White Sweeting Winter Sweet Paradise