← All varieties

Beurre d'Aremberg

Pear

Beurre d'Aremberg

Origin/History

The Beurre d'Aremberg is an old Belgian variety raised by Monseigneur (the Abbé) Deschamps, in the garden of the Hospice des Orphelines (Orphan Hospital) at Enghien, Belgium. According to Hovey, it was raised about thirty-five years before his 1852 account (i.e., circa 1817). Deschamps initially called it, after the place of origin, Beurré des Orphelines; M. Van Mons soon after named it Beurré Beauchamps (in honor of its discoverer); others called it Beurré d'Hardenpont; and finally the name Beurré d'Aremberg was given to it by mistake but, becoming most general, was retained. Bunyard cites Van Mons as the authority that it was obtained at Enghien by Abbé Deschamps in the garden of the Orphanage of that town. Hedrick (1922) notes the origin is in dispute.

The variety was introduced to England upwards of twenty-five years before 1852 (i.e., in the mid-1820s). The true Beurré d'Aremberg of the Abbé Deschamps was sent to America about 1827 by Thomas Andrew Knight, President of the London Horticultural Society, to the Hon. John Lowell of Boston, from which source it was disseminated in the United States. The American Pomological Society recommended the variety for cultivation in 1848, but in 1871 the name disappeared from the Society's catalog.

A long-standing confusion exists between Beurre d'Aremberg and Glout Morceau. As early as 1805, M. Noisette, a Paris nurseryman, introduced to Paris a fine pear which he brought from the Duc d'Aremberg's garden in Belgium and which was widely disseminated as the Beurré d'Aremberg; it subsequently proved to be the Glout Morceau. As a result, the Beurré d'Aremberg of many French catalogues is in fact the Glout Morceau. Hovey writes that probably not more than one in ten of the trees sold from French nurseries were the true d'Aremberg, that some doubted whether the true variety was even known in their collections, and that several English nurseries and many American nurserymen continued the same error. Elliott notes that it has also been confounded with Soldat Laboureur, from which it is likewise distinct.

The two pears (d'Aremberg and Glout Morceau) ripen at the same season and often have a great resemblance in fruit, but in all other characteristics they are scarcely more unlike. Distinguishing features given by Downing and Hovey: the d'Aremberg fruit has a short, thicker stalk usually bent to one side; its flavor is vinous instead of sugary. The habit of growth of the Beurré d'Aremberg is erect and regular, that of the Glout Morceau spreading and irregular. The wood of Beurré d'Aremberg is slender, long-jointed, with short roundish buds, and of a clear yellowish brown; that of Glout Morceau is stout, short-jointed, with very prominent pointed diverging buds, and of a dark olive color. The leaves of Beurré d'Aremberg are narrow and folded with scarcely any serrature (Hovey), or more deeply serrated than Glout Morceau (Downing/Elliott — Elliott describes its leaves as "narrow, deeply serrated"); those of Glout Morceau are broad, wavy, and deeply serrated (Hovey).

European writers, in the opinion of Hedrick, have held that Beurré d'Aremberg occupies first place among the pears produced by French and Belgian pomologists. Hovey similarly states that "among all the pears, which have been produced by the French and Belgian pomologists, none hold a higher rank than the Beurré d'Aremberg."

Tree

Habit: Erect and regular, with upright branches, rather compact and regular in growth; the lateral shoots often pushing near the extremity of the main branches (Hovey). Hedrick: medium in size and vigor, upright, very hardy and very productive. Bunyard: growth very stout, moderate; fertility variable.

Vigor: Moderately vigorous (Hovey); medium (Hedrick). Elliott describes the wood as "strong."

Hardiness/health: Very hardy (Hedrick, Elliott). However, Downing states the tree is "unhealthy and subject to canker." Hedrick (1921) notes the trees are "rather small, short-lived."

Bearing: Most productive; bears young on the pear root, annually and abundantly (Elliott, Hovey); generally comes into bearing about the third year (Hovey). Bears most abundantly (Downing). The fruit has the rare merit of not being blown off the trees easily by heavy winds (Hovey). To have the fruit of good size, it is necessary to thin them considerably (Hovey).

Stock/soil: Grows freely either upon the quince or pear (Hovey); good on quince (Bunyard). Prefers a good strong loamy soil, but produces good crops on soils that are quite unfavorable to some other varieties (Hovey); a warm, rich soil suits it best (Elliott). Bunyard notes it does not thrive in all soils. Hedrick reports the poor (acidulous, astringent) fruits are always borne on heavy, cold clays and in cold climates.

Trunk and branches: Medium in thickness and smoothness (Hedrick).

Wood/branchlets: Clear yellowish brown, sprinkled/dotted with oblong, pale brown (Hovey) or pale gray (Elliott) or pale (Downing) specks/lenticels; on trees of some age, slightly raised above the bark (Hovey). Growth erect, rather slender, long-jointed (Hovey, Elliott). Hedrick: branchlets slender, short, light brown mingled with green, smooth, glabrous, with numerous, small, raised lenticels.

Buds: Small, short, plump (Hovey, Hedrick); roundish (Hovey, in comparison passage). Leaf-buds small, short, plump, free; leaf-scars with prominent shoulders (Hedrick). Flower-buds oval, with smooth brown scales (Hovey); small, short, sharply pointed, free, singly on short spurs (Hedrick).

Leaves: Medium size (Hovey); 3 inches long, 1½ inches wide (Hedrick 1921); 3½ inches long, 1½ inches wide (Hedrick 1922); large, upfolded, finely serrate (Bunyard). Oblong, tapering little to the end, rather light green, nearly entire on the old wood, but slightly serrated on the young growth, somewhat folded, and often with the mid-rib much recurved (Hovey). Apex taper-pointed; margin glandless, finely serrate (Hedrick). Elliott describes the leaves as narrow and deeply serrated; Downing describes them as more deeply serrated (comparison with Glout Morceau). Petiole medium length (Hovey); 1¼ inches long (Hedrick 1921); 1½ inches long (Hedrick 1922).

Flowers: Large, yellowish white; petals oblong, recurved at the edges, and tapering much to the claw, which is long (Hovey).

Fruit

Size

Medium, often large (Hovey); about three inches long and two and three quarters in diameter (Hovey); above medium (Elliott); large (Hedrick). Bunyard: 4 by 3½ inches or larger.

Form

Obovate (Downing), narrowing a good deal to the stalk; obovate, slightly angular, full at the crown, and tapering gradually to the stem (Hovey); obovate, obtuse pyriform, tapering toward the stem (Elliott); obovate-pyriform, ribbed (Hedrick); round conical, uneven, a little ribbed round the eye and generally bossed (Bunyard).

Stem/Stalk

Short, about half an inch (Hovey, Downing) to an inch (Downing); ¾ inch (Hedrick 1922, Bunyard); 1 inch (Hedrick 1921). Thick, very fleshy, especially where it joins the fruit (Downing); stout, knobby and uneven, green and brown, fleshy at the base (Hovey); short, stout, uneven (Elliott); very stout, woody, obliquely inserted (Bunyard). Usually planted/inserted very obliquely, often bent to one side (Downing, Hovey, Hedrick, Elliott); set obliquely without any depression (Elliott) or without any cavity (Hovey), or at most under a small protuberance (Bunyard); often terminating in a fleshy junction (Elliott).

Cavity

Lacking; drawn up in an oblique lip about the stem (Hedrick); without any cavity (Hovey); without depression (Elliott); under a small protuberance (Bunyard).

Calyx/Eye

Small, closed (Hedrick, Hovey, Elliott); short and small (Downing); open (Bunyard). Segments/lobes short, sometimes entirely absent/lacking (Hovey, Hedrick, Elliott).

Basin

Deep (Downing, Hedrick, Elliott — "rather deep"), smooth (Hedrick, Hovey); smooth, funnel-shaped, with the eye deeply sunk (Hovey).

Skin

Thick, rather uneven, somewhat rough/roughish (Downing, Hovey, Hedrick); fairly smooth (Bunyard). Color: pale greenish yellow, becoming yellow at maturity (Downing); pale green, becoming pale yellow when mature (Hovey); dull pale green, at maturity light yellow clouded with green (Elliott); greenish-yellow becoming yellow at maturity (Hedrick 1922); yellow with small patches of russet all over and brown red flush (Bunyard). With many tracings and spots/markings of light or bright cinnamon russet over the surface, russeted around the eye/calyx end (Downing, Hovey, Elliott, Hedrick). Dots numerous, cinnamon-russet (Hedrick).

Flesh and Flavor

Flesh white (Downing, Hedrick, Elliott) or yellowish white (Hovey) or nearly white (Bunyard); buttery and melting (Downing); rather coarse, melting and very juicy (Hovey); juicy, melting (Elliott); very juicy, melting (Hedrick); juicy and sweet, sometimes a little gritty (Bunyard).

Flavor: "An abundant, rich, delicious vinous juice. Very good" (Downing); "exceedingly rich, vinous, refreshing and delicious, with a high perfume" (Hovey); "vinous" (Elliott); "vinous or acidulous; quality very good" (Hedrick); "with a characteristic aroma" (Bunyard). Refreshing, vinous taste (Hedrick). When not properly ripened the pears are highly acidulous and so astringent as to be almost intolerable to the taste (Hedrick).

Core and Seeds

Core large (Hovey, Hedrick); medium (Elliott). Seeds large, roundish, plump, pale brown (Hovey); large, roundish, plump (Hedrick); light brown, acutely pointed (Elliott).

Season

Usual season of maturity is January (Hovey), but often ripens as early as November (Hovey) and, with little care, may frequently be kept till February (Hovey). December (Downing); December to January (Hedrick); November to January (Bunyard); may be gathered and ripened at will from December to February (Elliott). Long-keeping; keeps and matures with perhaps less care than most other winter fruits in the house (Downing).

Uses

Dessert (Bunyard). A first-class fruit for the table when properly ripened. The fruit, when gathered, if put into clean barrels or boxes and placed in a cool situation, ripens as freely as the Baldwin apple (Hovey). In the far West, the crop ripens better, and the pears are splendid (Hedrick 1921) or excellent (Hedrick 1922) winter fruits. In eastern America the fruits often do not ripen, producing poor, acidulous, astringent results (Hedrick).

Subtypes/Variants

Not described in source.

Other

Hedrick (1921) notes that the name is spelled by many writers "Beurré d'Aremberg." Hovey emphasizes the importance, in the identification of varieties, of the wood, leaves, and habit of growth of the tree, given the long-perpetuated confusion with Glout Morceau despite the trees being so very dissimilar.

Book Sources

Described in 6 period pomological works

Nursery Catalog Sources

Found in 3 catalogs (1886–1911) from Alabama, England

View original book sources (6)

Beurré d'Aremberg.

Duc d'Aremberg. Deschamps. Colmar Deschamps. D'Aremberg Parfait. L'Orpheline. Beurré des Orphelines. Beurre Burchardt. Orpheline d'Enghien. Beurre Deschamps. Délices des Orphelins.

The Beurré d'Aremberg is a fine fruit, high-flavored, bears most abundantly, and always keeps and matures with perhaps less care than most other winter fruits in the house.

The Beurré d'Aremberg was raised by the Abbé Deschamps, in the garden of the Hospice des Orphelines, at Enghien. The Beurré d'Aremberg of many French catalogues is the Glout Morceau. The two sorts are easily distinguished. The fruit of the d'Aremberg has a short, or thicker stalk, usually bent to one side; its flavor is vinous instead of sugary, and its wood not so strong, with more deeply serrated leaves. Branches clear yellowish brown, dotted with pale specks. Tree unhealthy and subject to canker.

Fruit obovate, but narrowing a good deal to the stalk. Skin thick, rather uneven, pale greenish yellow, becoming yellow at maturity, with many tracings and spots of light russet. Stalk short, half an inch to an inch long, thick, and very fleshy, especially where it joins the fruit, and usually planted very obliquely. Calyx short and small, set in a deep basin. Flesh white, buttery, and melting, with an abundant, rich, delicious vinous juice. Very good. December.

A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)

BEURRÉ D'ARENBERG¹

  1. Trans. Lond. Hort. Soc. 5:406. 1824. 2. Lindley Guide Orch. Gard. 392. 1831. 3. Prince Pom. Man. 1:51. 1831. 4. Kenrick Am. Orch. 188. 1832. 5. Ibid. 156. 1841. 6. Gard. Chron. 716, fig. 2. 1844. 7. Downing Fr. Trees Am. 423, fig. 195. 1845. 8. Proc. Nat. Con. Fr. Gr. 51. 1848. 9. Hovey Fr. Am. 1:1, Pl. 1851. 10. Mass. Hort. Soc. Rpt. 93, Pl. 1852. 11. Mas Le Verger 1:161, fig. 79. 1866-73. 12. Hogg Fruit Man. 510. 1884.

Orpheline d'Enghien. 13. Ann. Pom. Belge 3:35, Pl. 1855. 14. Guide Prat. 108, 292. 1876.

In favorable locations this pear seems to possess all of the characters which constitute a first-class fruit; but, notwithstanding, although it has been in the country nearly a century, it is now scarcely to be found in the nurseries, and orchard trees are becoming rare. The fruits are distinguished by their refreshing, vinous taste and long-keeping qualities. Very often, however, they do not ripen in eastern America, and when not properly ripened the pears are highly acidulous and so astringent as to be almost intolerable to the taste. The frequency with which these poor fruits are borne, always on heavy, cold clays and in cold climates, coupled with rather small, short-lived trees, condemn the variety for most pear regions in the East. In the far West, the crop ripens better, and the pears are splendid winter fruits. The merits of the variety are so varying in New York that it is not now worth while attempting to bring it into new life.

Beurré d'Arenberg, in the opinion of some European writers, holds first place among the pears produced by French and Belgian pomologists. Unfortunately, Beurré d'Arenberg and Glou Morceau are often mistaken the one for the other. Beurré d'Arenberg was raised by Monseigneur Deschamps, Abbé of the Orphan Hospital, Enghien, Belgium. At about the same time, M. Noisette, a nurseryman of Paris, sent out Glou Morceau, which he had procured from the gardens of the Duc d'Arenberg, under the name Beurré d'Arenberg, so that there were two distinct varieties in cultivation under the same name. The true Beurré d'Arenberg of the Abbé Deschamps came to this country about 1827, having been sent over by Thomas Andrew Knight, President of the London Horticultural Society, to the Hon. John Lowell of Boston. The American Pomological Society recommended this variety for cultivation in 1848, but in 1871 the name disappeared from the Society's catalog.

¹ The name is spelled by many writers Beurré d'Aremberg.

Tree medium in size and vigor, upright, very hardy and very productive; trunk and branches medium in thickness and smoothness; branchlets slender, short, light brown mingled with green, smooth, glabrous, with numerous, small, raised lenticels. Leaf-buds small, short, plump, free; leaf-scars with prominent shoulders. Leaves 3 in. long; 1½ in. wide; apex taper-pointed; margin glandless, finely serrate; petiole 1¼ in. long. Flower-buds small, short, sharply pointed, free, singly on short spurs.

Fruit ripe December to January; large, obovate-pyriform, ribbed; stem 1 in. long, thick, fleshy at the base, obliquely inserted; cavity lacking, drawn up in an oblique lip about the stem; calyx small, closed; lobes short, sometimes lacking; basin deep, smooth; skin roughish, thick, uneven; color yellow, with patches and tracings of russet especially around the calyx end; dots numerous, cinnamon-russet; flesh white, very juicy, melting, vinous or acidulous; quality very good. Core large; seeds large, roundish, plump.

U.P. Hedrick, The Pears of New York (1921)

THE BEURRÉ D'AREMBERG PEAR.

Beurré d'Aremberg. Hort. Trans. vol. v. p. 406.

Duc d'Aremberg, ) Deschamps, > Hort. Soc. Catalogue, 3d Ed. 1842. L'Orpoline, ) Beurré des Orphelines, ) Beurré Deschamps, } of some Collections. Colmar Deschamps, D'Aremberg Parfait, ) Soldat Labourer, of some French and Belgian Collections.

Among all the pears, which have been produced by the French and Belgian pomologists, none hold a higher rank than the Beurré d'Aremberg. It possesses, in a remarkable degree, all those superior qualities—hardiness, adaptation to various soils, productiveness, ripening freely, and keeping well—which constitute a first-class fruit. It is now upwards of twenty-five years since it was first introduced to England, and more than twenty years since it was added to American collections, through the liberality of the late Mr. Knight, who sent it to the Hon. John Lowell, from which source it has been disseminated; but it is, with us, comparatively a new variety, and, as yet, very little known. M. Noisette, a celebrated French cultivator, many years ago, as early as 1805, introduced to Paris a fine pear, which he brought from the Duc d'Aremberg's garden, in Belgium, which was widely disseminated as the Beurré d'Aremberg; but it subsequently proved to be the Glout Morceau, and hence has arisen the confusion which now exists in regard to these varieties. Probably not more than one in ten of all the trees which are sold from the French nurseries, are the true d'Aremberg; and it has been doubted by some, whether the latter is even known in their collections. Several of the English nurseries also disseminate the Glout Morceau under the name of the Beurré d'Aremberg, and many American nurserymen still continue the same error. It is singular that so great a mistake should have been so long perpetuated, when the trees are so very dissimilar; and it shows how important, in the identification of varieties, are the wood, leaves, and habit of growth of the tree.

The Beurré d'Aremberg was raised about thirty-five years ago, by the Abbé Deschamps, at Enghein, in the garden of the Hospice des Orphelines, in that city. Deschamps called it, after the place, Beurré des Orphelines; M. Van Mons soon after named it Beurré Beauchamps, in honor of its discoverer; others called it Beurré d'Hardenpont; and finally, the name of Beurré d'Aremberg was given to it by mistake, but, becoming most general, it has been retained.

After so many years of confusion, in regard to the Beurré d'Aremberg and Glout Morceau, it is a principal object with cultivators to know every means of identifying the two kinds; and we have selected these two varieties, not only on account of their intrinsic merits, but in order to bring together a comparison in this respect. The fruits of the two ripen at the same season, and often have a great resemblance; but in all other characteristics there can be no two kinds scarcely more unlike. The habit of growth of the Beurré d'Aremberg is erect and regular,—that of the Glout Morceau, spreading and irregular. This we have illustrated in the vignettes accompanying our descriptions of each, which are taken from our specimen trees, three years planted out, and now in a bearing state. The wood of the Beurré d'Aremberg is slender, long-jointed, with short, roundish buds, and of a clear yellowish brown;—that of the Glout Morceau, stout, short-jointed, with very prominent, pointed, diverging buds, and of a dark olive. The leaves of the former are narrow and folded, with scarcely any serrature;—those of the latter, broad, wavy, and deeply serrated.

The Beurré d'Aremberg is a most productive variety, and to have the fruit of good size it is necessary to thin them considerably. The fruit has, also, the rare merit of not being blown off the trees easily by heavy winds. It grows freely either upon the quince or pear, and comes into bearing, generally, about the third year. It prefers a good strong loamy soil, but produces good crops on such as are quite unfavorable to some other varieties. The fruit, when gathered, if put into clean barrels or boxes and placed in a cool situation, ripens as freely as the Baldwin apple.

Tree.—Moderately vigorous, erect, with upright branches, rather compact and regular in growth; the lateral shoots often pushing near the extremity of the main branches.

Wood.—Clear yellowish brown, sprinkled with oblong, pale brown specks; on trees of some age, slightly raised above the bark; growth erect, rather slender, long-jointed, with small, short, plump buds: Flower-buds oval, with smooth brown scales.

Leaves.—Medium size, oblong, tapering little to the end, rather light green, nearly entire on the old wood, but slightly serrated on the young growth, somewhat folded, and often with the mid-rib much recurved: petioles medium length.

Flowers.—Large, yellowish white; petals oblong, recurved at the edges, and tapering much to the claw, which is long.

Fruit.—Medium size, often large, about three inches long and two and three quarters in diameter: Form, obovate, slightly angular, full at the crown, and tapering gradually to the stem: Skin, somewhat rough, pale green, becoming pale yellow when mature, russeted around the eye, with many tracings and slight markings of bright russet over the surface: Stem, short, about half an inch, stout, knobby and uneven, green and brown, fleshy at the base, and very obliquely inserted without any cavity: Eye, small, closed, and deeply sunk in a smooth, funnel-shaped basin; segments of the calyx short, sometimes entirely absent: Flesh, yellowish white, rather coarse, melting and very juicy: Flavor, exceedingly rich, vinous, refreshing and delicious, with a high perfume: Core, large: Seeds, large, roundish, plump, pale brown.

The usual season of maturity is January, but it often ripens as early as November, and, with little care, it may frequently be kept till February.

— C.M. Hovey, The Fruits of America (1852)

BEURRE D'AREMBERG.

Due d'Aremberg, Soldat Laboureur, of some, Beurré des Orphelines, Colmar Deschamps, Deschamps, Orpheline d'Enghein. L'Orphelines, D'Aremberg Parfait,

A foreign variety which has been often confounded with Glout Morceau and Soldat Laboureur, from both of which it is distinct. The wood is strong, long-jointed, yellowish brown, dotted with pale gray specks; leaves, narrow, deeply serrated; trees, very hardy, bear young on the pear root, annually and abundantly; the fruit hangs well, and may be gathered and ripened at will from December to February. A warm, rich soil suits it best.

Fruit, above medium, obovate, obtuse pyriform, tapering toward the stem, where it often terminates in a fleshy junction; color, dull pale green, at maturity light yellow, clouded with green, with traces and patches of light cinnamon russet; stem, short, stout, uneven, set obliquely, without depression; calyx, small, closed, segments short; basin, rather deep; core, medium; seeds, light brown, acutely pointed; flesh, white, juicy, melting, vinous. December to February.

— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)

BEURRE D'ARENBERG. Her. Pom. II., 70. G. Die Arenberg. (Orpheline d'Enghien, Colmar Deschamps.) Dessert, November to January, 4 by 3½ or larger, round conical, uneven, a little ribbed round eye and generally bossed. Skin, fairly smooth. Colour, yellow with small patches of russet all over and brown red flush. Flesh, nearly white, juicy and sweet with a characteristic aroma, sometimes a little gritty. Eye, open. Stem, ¾ in., very stout, woody, obliquely inserted under a small protuberance. Growth, very stout, moderate; fertility variable. Leaf, large, upfolded, finely serrate. Origin, according to Van Mons this was obtained at Enghien by Abbe Deschamps in a garden of the Orphanage of this town. A good fruit doing well on quince but it does not thrive in all soils.

— E.A. Bunyard, A Handbook of Hardy Fruits (1920)

BEURRE D'ARENBERG. The fruits of this variety are distinguished by their refreshing, vinous taste and long-keeping qualities. Very often, however, they do not ripen in eastern America, and when not properly ripened the pears are highly acidulous and so astringent as to be almost intolerable to the taste. The frequency with which these poor fruits are borne, always on heavy, cold clays and in cold climates, coupled with rather small, short-lived trees, condemn the variety for most pear regions in the East. In the far West, the crop ripens better and the pears are excellent winter fruits. The variety is an old Belgian one, the origin of which is in dispute. Tree medium in size and vigor, upright, very hardy and very productive; trunk and branches medium in thickness and smoothness. Leaves 3½ inches long, 1½ inches wide; apex taper-pointed; margin glandless, finely serrate; petiole 1½ inches long. Fruit ripe December-January; large, obovate-pyriform, ribbed; stem ¾ inch long, thick, fleshy at the base, obliquely inserted; cavity lacking, drawn up in an oblique lip about the stem; calyx small, closed, lobes short, sometimes lacking; basin deep, smooth; skin roughish, thick, uneven; color greenish-yellow becoming yellow at maturity, with patches and tracings of russet especially around the calyx end; dots numerous, cinnamon-russet; flesh white, very juicy, melting, vinous or acidulous; quality very good; core large; seeds large, roundish, plump.

U.P. Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)
BEURRE D'ARENBERG Beurre Burchardt Beurre Deschamps Beurré Beauchamps Beurré D'Arenberg Beurré Deschamps Beurré d'Hardenpont Beurré des Orphelines Colmar Deschamps D'Aremberg Parfait Deschamps Die Arenberg Duc d'Aremberg Due d'Aremberg Délices des Orphelins L'Orpheline L'Orphelines L'Orpoline Orpheline d'Enghein Orpheline d'Enghien Soldat Labourer Soldat Laboureur Beurre Duval Bon-Chrétien Fondant Delices d'Hardenpont of Angers Duc Alfred de Croy Duchesse de Brabant (De Capeinick) Glou Morceau Soldat Labourer VICOMTE DE SPOELBERCH