← All varieties

Red Canada

Apple

Red Canada

Origin / History

An old American apple of New England origin. Elliott calls it "probably a native of Massachusetts," and Hedrick says it "probably originated in New England a hundred or more years ago." Beach's earliest reference is Thacher, 1822, under the name Nonsuch. In 1849 Cole described it as the Old Nonsuch. According to Beach it appears to have been brought into Western New York from the vicinity of Toronto, Canada, and afterwards cultivated in that region under the name Canada Red. The names Red Canada and Canada Red were used interchangeably. The earliest mention Beach finds under either is that of Watts and Downing in 1847. In Michigan it was often cultivated under the name Steele's Red Winter, and in some portions of Eastern New York it was grown as Bristol. Thomas holds it wholly distinct from the Nonsuch of England, and to prevent confusion with that apple the name Red Canada is preferred.

Formerly much grown in New England and other parts of the East, Connecticut and Massachusetts especially. Downing says it is "not now much planted" there "on account of its small size and poor fruit," but that it succeeds well in Western New York, Ohio, and Michigan. Thomas has it succeeding in New England, New York, and Ohio. Hedrick says it has been most largely planted in New England, New York, and Michigan. Beach finds it pretty generally distributed throughout New York State. In some few localities its cultivation in commercial orchards is increasing, but it has seldom been planted to any considerable extent, and generally it is found only in old orchards. Planted at the Central Experimental Farm, Agassiz, B.C., in the spring of 1890.

Elliott calls it "one of the most valuable for orchard, or garden," and Thomas "one of the finest table apples." Beach places it as a red winter apple in the same group with Baldwin and Esopus Spitsenburg. When well grown and in prime condition he counts it one of the best apples of its season for dessert, on account of its desirable size, attractive form and color, and superior quality. Hedrick: "Were the trees as satisfactory as the fruit, Red Canada would take high rank among the commercial apples of the country."

Tree

Of slender, slow, irregular growth. Most authors call the growth slender. Warder and Downing call the tree thrifty, and Warder twiggy. Shoots diverging (Elliott), rather slender (Thomas). Beach calls it but a moderate grower, and Hedrick says the trees "lack in vigor." Beach's technical description nonetheless gives the tree medium to large, moderately vigorous to vigorous. The Agassiz station reports a vigorous and spreading grower.

Branches short, stout, curved, crooked. Form upright to roundish, rather dense. Twigs medium in length, straight or nearly so, rather slender to moderately stout; internodes below medium to long. Young wood brownish olive (Downing). Bark olive-green tinged with reddish brown, netted or streaked with thin scarf-skin, slightly pubescent. Lenticels scattering, not very conspicuous, small, round, slightly raised. Buds prominent, large to medium, long, narrow, plump, acute, free or nearly so, slightly pubescent. Leaves medium to broad, rather thin; wavy (Thomas).

Somewhat lacking in hardiness (Beach); "precariously hardy" (Hedrick). To overcome its slender growth it should be top-worked on a hardier, stronger-growing variety. Beach names Baldwin or Northern Spy; Budd and Hansen name Northern Spy, Tolman, or other strong-growing varieties.

Warder calls the tree healthy. It is productive by most accounts and very productive by Downing's. Budd and Hansen say productive in most localities. Elliott makes it productive when it has rich, strong soil, on which the fruit is always fair and of uniform size. Thomas counts the slender growth of the tree, the frequent scabbiness of the fruit, and its moderate crops in some localities as the chief drawbacks on its value. Beach finds it in some cases an annual bearer but more often not a sure cropper. Hedrick says the trees "signally fail," being "subject to most of the troubles that apple flesh is heir to, fastidious as to soils, and seldom sure or annual bearers."

Fruit

Size: Medium to large. Most authors give medium. Beach gives medium to nearly large, and Budd and Hansen and Hedrick medium to large. Uniform in size and shape, pretty uniform by Beach's account. Downing names its small size, with its poor fruit, as the reason it is no longer much planted in Connecticut and Massachusetts.

Form: Roundish to oblate, globular-conic, inclined to conic, and somewhat flattened at the base or stem end. Regular, nearly symmetrical, but sometimes elliptical or obscurely ribbed, with sides a little unequal (Beach). Indistinctly or obscurely angular (Warder, Budd and Hansen).

Stem: Short to long, stout to slender. Elliott finds it varying from short and stout to slender and long. Beach gives medium to rather slender, pubescent, and Thomas about an inch long. Inclined (Warder).

Cavity: Usually large; deep, wide to very wide or broad, acuminate or acute. Russeted, often partly so, with radiating green or russet rays (Beach); a touch of light russet (Elliott). Regular (Elliott), even (Thomas), usually symmetrical but sometimes slightly furrowed (Beach); wavy (Warder, Budd and Hansen).

Calyx: Small, closed or partly open, pubescent (Beach). Segments long. Calyx tube conical, elongated cone-shape or somewhat funnel-form (Beach). Stamens marginal (Beach).

Basin: Small, narrow, rather abrupt, shallow to moderately deep. Furrowed, folded, or somewhat irregular, sometimes slightly wrinkled, often somewhat oblique. Elliott calls it open, of moderate depth, slightly furrowed or uneven. Thomas calls it nearly even and moderate.

Skin: Smooth or nearly smooth, especially toward the cavity, slightly rough about the basin (Beach). Elliott calls the skin thin and tender; Beach calls it tough. Ground rich, clear yellow or rather clear light yellow, or green. Largely or nearly wholly overspread, on the side exposed to the sun by Elliott's account, with a fine deep red blush or with deep red and crimson. The red is indistinctly striped with deeper red, and somewhat striped or splashed on the sunny side. Elliott describes the red as bright, in two shades, light and dark, intermingling or striped; Warder as mixed and striped bright red. The Agassiz station gives green nearly covered with dark red, and Lowther yellow-red. Prevailing effect bright deep red; handsome, beautiful, very attractive.

Dots: Many, gray or light gray, grayish or fawn-colored, sometimes greenish (Downing), gray and yellow (Budd and Hansen). Conspicuous or distinct. Thomas alone calls them rather indistinct and whitish. Toward the cavity they are scattering, large, and often elongated as in Baldwin and Esopus Spitsenburg; toward the apex they become more numerous and smaller (Beach). Warder calls them indented and elongated near the stem, "as in Esopus." Elliott says they give at first sight an appearance of a somewhat rough exterior.

Flesh and flavor: Flesh yellowish white or white, whitish with a yellow or greenish tinge (Beach). Firm, crisp, breaking, compact, fine-grained, tender, juicy, "abounding with a brisk, refreshing juice" (Downing). Flavor sprightly, brisk, aromatic, rich, agreeably subacid, "high and excellent" (Thomas), "delicious" (Warder). The Agassiz station alone calls it nearly sweet. Downing has it "retaining its fine, delicate flavor to the last." Beach finds it becoming rather too mild toward the close of the season, and apt to lose much of its high flavor after midwinter although the fruit may remain apparently sound.

Quality very good to best. Lowther and the Agassiz station say very good, Warder "best, for table," and Beach good to best. Beach finds the quality varying much in different seasons and localities. On heavy clay soils it is in some seasons decidedly inferior to Baldwin and would be rated only fair to good. On certain fertile soils of a gravelly or sandy nature in favorable seasons it develops color, flavor, and quality fully equal to Esopus Spitsenburg.

Core and seeds: Core small to medium, compact, close or closed, sessile, axile or nearly so; regular (Warder). Warder alone calls it large. Cells symmetrical, closed or slit. Core lines clasping (Beach); barely clasping (Budd and Hansen). Carpels usually smooth, roundish, narrowing somewhat toward the apex, mucronate, but slightly emarginate if at all (Beach). Seeds ovate-pyriform (Elliott). Beach describes them as very numerous, medium to rather large, angular, long, moderately wide, plump, obtuse. Warder and Budd and Hansen call them imperfect.

Season

A winter apple, recorded from October into May. Most dated accounts open the season in December or January and close it from February to April. Downing carries it to May, and Thomas says it keeps through winter, often late in spring. Hedrick opens it in October. Beach calls the season somewhat variable and gives November to March or later for home use. His commercial limit is January or February in ordinary storage and April in cold storage. It stands heat well before going into storage and goes down gradually (Beach).

Uses

A dessert and table apple; kitchen and market (Lowther). Beach finds it well adapted to either general or special markets, where it often brings more than average prices.

Subtypes / Variants

Not described in source.

Other

Not the Canada Red of some portions of Ontario. Waugh recognizes Roseau as the correct name for that apple, which Beach calls quite distinct from Red Canada.

Book Sources

Described in 8 period pomological works

Nursery Catalog Sources

Found in 25 catalogs (1864–1921) from Alabama, California, Illinois, Missouri, Oregon, Washington

View original book sources (9)

Red Canada.

Steele's Red Winter of Mich., | Old Nonsuch, Richfield Nonsuch.

American : probably a native of Massachusetts. Tree, slender growth ; shoots diverging ; requires rich, strong soil, when it is productive, and always fair and uniform size of fruit. One of the most valuable for orchard, or garden.

Fruit, medium ; form, roundish conical, flattened at stem end ; color, rich, clear, yellow ground ; when exposed to the sun, overspread with bright, handsome red, two shades, light and dark, intermingling, or striped, many light gray dots, presenting at first sight an appearance of a somewhat rough exterior ; skin, thin, tender ; stem, varying from short and stout to slender and long, usually as seen in our figure ; cavity, deep, regular, a touch of light russet ; calyx, small, closed ; basin, open, moderate depth, slightly furrowed, or uneven ; flesh, yellowish white, crisp, tender, juicy, sprightly, sub-acid, aromatic ; core, small, compact ; seeds, ovate pyriform. January to April.

— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)

Red Canada. STEEL'S RED.

Origin New England. Tree thrifty, healthy, but slender, twiggy, productive.

Fruit medium, globular-conic, indistinctly angular; Surface smooth, yellow, covered with mixed and striped bright red; Dots numerous, gray, indented, elongated near the stem, as in Esopus.

Basin shallow, folded; Eye small, closed.

Cavity wide, acute, wavy; Stem long, inclined.

Core regular, closed, large; Seeds imperfect; Flesh yellowish-white, breaking, crisp, fine-grained, tender, juicy; Flavor sub-acid, aromatic, delicious; Quality best, for table; Season, December to February.

— John A. Warder, American Pomology: Apples (1867)

Red Canada.

Old Nonsuch, of Mass. Poland. Richfield Nonsuch. Steele's Red Winter.

An old fruit, formerly much grown in Connecticut and Massachusetts, but is not now much planted, on account of its small size and poor fruit ; succeeds well in Western New York, Ohio, and Michigan. Tree thrifty, but of slender growth ; very productive. Young wood brownish olive.

Fruit medium, oblate, inclining to conic. Skin yellow, mostly shaded with deep red or crimson, somewhat striped or splashed on the sunny side, and thickly sprinkled with gray, and sometimes greenish dots. Stalk short, inserted in a broad, deep cavity. Calyx closed. Segments long, in a small, narrow, somewhat irregular basin. Core small, close. Flesh white, tender, crisp, abounding with a brisk, refreshing juice, and retaining its fine, delicate flavor to the last. Very good to best. January to May.

— A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)

Red Canada.* (Nonsuch, Old Nonsuch of Massachusetts, Richfield Nonsuch of Ohio.) Medium in size, roundish-conical, regular; nearly the whole surface covered with red, and interspersed with large and rather indistinct whitish dots; stalk about an inch long, in a very wide and even cavity; basin nearly even, moderate; flesh fine-grained, compact, with a rich, sub-acid, high and excellent flavor. Keeps through winter. Shoots rather slender, leaves wavy. Productive. Succeeds in New England, New York, and Ohio. This is wholly distinct from the Nonsuch of England, to prevent confusion with which the name Red Canada is preferred. One of the finest table apples, often keeping late in spring. The slender growth of the tree, the frequent scabbiness of the fruit, and its moderate crops in some localities, are the chief drawbacks on its value. Fig. 450.

— John J. Thomas, The American Fruit Culturist (1903)

RED CANADA.

REFERENCES.

  1. Thacher, 1822:131. 2. Fessenden, 1828:131. 3. Manning, Mag. Hort., 7:47. 1841. 4. Hovey, Ib., 13:75. 1847. fig. 5. Watts and Downing, Horticulturist, 1:482. 1847. 6. Downing, Ib., 2:289. 1847. 7. Hovey, Mag. Hort., 14:124. 1848. 8. Horticulturist, 2:483, 544. 1848. 9. Thomas, 1849:171. fig. 10. Cole, 1849:127. 11. Emmons, Nat. Hist. N. Y., 3:101. 1851. col. pl. No. 42. 12. Am. Pom. Soc. Cat., 1852. 13. Mag. Hort., 19:68. 1853. 14. Elliott, 1854:102. fig. 15. Hooper, 1857:76. 16. Downing, 1857:97. fig. 17. Warder, 1867:542. 18. Regel, 1868:465. 19. Barry, 1883:353. 20. Wickson, 1889:217. 21. Lyon, Mich. Hort. Soc. Rpt., 1890:296. 22. Bailey, An. Hort., 1892:247. 23. Amer. Gard., 20:104. 1899. 24. Budd-Hansen, 1903:161. 25. Powell and Fulton, U. S. B. P. I. Bul., 48:53. 1903. 26. Beach and Clark, N. Y. Sta. Bul., 248:140. 1904.

SYNONYMS. Bristol of some. Canada Red (25). Canada Redstreak (26). NONESUCH (2). NONSUCH (1, 3, 8, 13). Nonsuch (9). OLD NONSUCH (7, 10). Old Nonsuch (6, 9, 14, 15, 21, of Massachusetts 8 and 16). Red Canada (13, of Western New York 8 and 10). Red Winter (26). Richfield Nonsuch (10, 11, 14, 15, 16, of Ohio 9). Steele's Red Winter (20, 24, 25, 26, of Michigan 16). Steel's Red (17). Winter Nonsuch (10). Not the Canada Red of some portions of Ontario. See Roseau, page 292.

This is a red winter apple which belongs in the same group with Baldwin and Esopus Spitsenburg. When well grown and in prime condition it is one of the best apples of its season for dessert use on account of its desirable size, attractive form and color and superior quality. It is well adapted to either general or special markets and often brings more than average prices. The quality of the fruit varies much in different seasons and in different localities. When grown on heavy clay soils its quality in some seasons is decidedly inferior to that of Baldwin and would be rated only fair to good; but when grown on certain fertile soils of a gravelly or sandy nature in favorable seasons it develops color, flavor and quality fully equal to that of Esopus Spitsenburg. It stands heat well before going into storage and goes down gradually (26). Its season is somewhat variable. The commercial limit in ordinary storage is January or February, and in cold storage, April. Its season for home use usually extends from November to March or later. Although the fruit may remain apparently sound it is apt to lose much of its high flavor after midwinter. The tree is somewhat lacking in hardiness and is but a moderate grower. It should be top-worked on some hardier and more vigorous variety such as Baldwin or Northern Spy. In some cases it is an annual bearer but more often it is not a sure cropper. Waugh recognizes Roseau as the correct name for an apple which is commonly known in Ontario under the name of Canada Red. It is quite distinct from the variety above described.¹ For further consideration of this matter the reader is referred to Roseau, page 292.

[pages 466–467 not available in source OCR]

Historical. …recognized this name for the variety. In 1849 Cole (10) described it as the Old Nonsuch. It appears to have been brought into Western New York from the vicinity of Toronto, Canada, and afterwards cultivated in this region under the name Canada Red. The earliest mention we find of the variety under the name Red Canada or Canada Red, as these names appear to have been used interchangeably, is that of Watts and Downing in 1847 (5). In Michigan it has been often cultivated under the name of Steele's Red Winter. In some portions of Eastern New York it is grown under the name Bristol. It has been pretty generally distributed throughout the state. In some few localities its cultivation in commercial orchards is increasing but seldom has it been planted to any considerable extent, and, generally speaking, it is found only in old orchards.

TREE. Tree medium to large, moderately vigorous to vigorous; branches short, stout, curved, crooked. Form upright to roundish, rather dense. Twigs medium in length, straight or nearly so, rather slender to moderately stout; internodes below medium to long. Bark olive-green tinged with reddish-brown, netted or streaked with thin scarf-skin, slightly pubescent. Lenticels scattering, not very conspicuous, small, round, slightly raised. Buds prominent, large to medium, long, narrow, plump, acute, free or nearly so, slightly pubescent. Leaves medium to broad, rather thin.

FRUIT. Fruit medium to nearly large, pretty uniform in size and shape. Form roundish inclined to conic and somewhat flattened at the base, nearly symmetrical and pretty regular but sometimes elliptical or obscurely ribbed and with sides a little unequal. Stem medium to rather slender, pubescent. Cavity usually large, acuminate, deep, wide, often partly russeted and with radiating green or russet rays, usually symmetrical, sometimes slightly furrowed. Calyx small, closed or partly open, pubescent. Basin small, usually narrow, shallow to moderately deep and rather abrupt, furrowed and sometimes slightly wrinkled, often somewhat oblique. Skin tough, nearly smooth especially toward the cavity, slightly rough about the basin, rather clear light yellow or green largely overspread in well-colored specimens with a fine deep red blush, indistinctly striped with deeper red. Dots conspicuous, grayish or fawn colored. Toward the cavity they are scattering, large and often elongated as in Baldwin and Esopus Spitsenburg, but as they converge toward the apex they become more numerous and smaller. Prevailing effect very attractive bright deep red. Calyx tube elongated cone-shape or somewhat funnel-form. Stamens marginal. Core sessile, axile or nearly so, medium to rather small; cells symmetrical, closed or slit; core lines clasping. Carpels usually smooth, roundish, narrowing somewhat toward the apex, mucronate, but slightly emarginate if at all. Seeds very numerous, medium to rather large, angular, long, moderately wide, plump, obtuse. Flesh whitish with yellow or greenish tinge, firm, crisp, rather fine-grained, tender, juicy, aromatic, rich, agreeably subacid but becoming rather too mild toward the close of the season, good to best.

— S.A. Beach, The Apples of New York, Vol. 1 (1905)

Red Canada (Steele's Red Winter). — An old variety of American origin, formerly much grown in New England and other parts of the East; the tree is of irregular, slow growth and productive in most localities, but to overcome its slender growth should be top-grafted on Northern Spy, Tolman, or other strong-growing variety.

Red Canada.

Fruit medium to large, oblate, slightly conical, obscurely angular; surface smooth, rich yellow, mostly shaded with deep red and crimson, with rather indistinct stripes and splashes on sunny side; dots distinct, many, large, gray and yellow; cavity deep, wide, wavy, russeted; stem short, slender; basin narrow, abrupt, shallow, slightly wrinkled and irregular; calyx small, closed; segments long. Core small, barely clasping, closed; tube conical; seeds imperfect; flesh yellowish white, crisp, fine-grained, tender, juicy, brisk aromatic, subacid, very good to best. All winter.

— J.L. Budd & N.E. Hansen, American Horticultural Manual, Part II: Systematic Pomology (1914)

Red Canada (19) is a medium-sized apple of roundish (oblate) form. Skin color is yellow-red. Quality is very good. Use is both kitchen and market. Season is winter.

— Granville Lowther (ed.), Encyclopedia of Practical Horticulture (1914)

RED CANADA. Fig. 46. Canada Redstreak. Red Winter. Steele's Red. Were the trees as satisfactory as the fruit, Red Canada would take high rank among the commercial apples of the country. The apples are characterized by firm, crisp, fine-grained, juicy, aromatic, richly flavored flesh; they are medium to large, shapely, uniform in size and shape, and colored a beautiful fine, deep red, striped with deeper red on a background of yellow, the whole surface being conspicuously marked with large fawn-colored dots. The trees, however, signally fail; they are precariously hardy, lack in vigor, subject to most of the troubles that apple flesh is heir to, fastidious as to soils, and seldom sure or annual bearers. Red Canada probably originated in New England a hundred or more years ago, and has been most largely planted in New England, New York, and Michigan. Tree medium to large, vigorous, upright; branches short, stout, curved, crooked. Leaves broad, thin. Fruit medium to large, uniform in size and shape, round-conic, flattened at the base, symmetrical and regular, sometimes elliptical or obscurely ribbed and with sides a little unequal; stem slender, pubescent; cavity large, acuminate, deep, wide, often russeted and with radiating green or russet rays, symmetrical, sometimes furrowed; calyx small, closed or partly open, pubescent; basin small, narrow, shallow, abrupt, furrowed and sometimes wrinkled, often oblique; skin tough, smooth toward the cavity, rough about the basin, light yellow overspread with a deep red blush, indistinctly striped with deeper red; dots conspicuous, gray or fawn-colored, towards the cavity scattering, large and elongated but towards the apex more numerous and smaller; prevailing effect deep red; calyx-tube elongated-cone-shape; stamens marginal; core sessile, axile, small; cells symmetrical, closed or slit; core-lines clasping; carpels smooth, round, narrowing toward the apex, mucronate; seeds numerous, large, angular, long, wide, plump, obtuse; flesh yellow, firm, crisp, fine-grained, tender, juicy, aromatic, rich, agreeably subacid; good to best; October to March.

— U.P. Hedrick, Cyclopedia of Hardy Fruits (1922)

Planted Spring 1890. Tree a vigorous and spreading grower. Fruit of medium size, conical. Skin green, nearly covered with dark red. Flesh white, firm, crisp, nearly sweet, quality very good. Season Winter.

— Central Experimental Farm, Central Experimental Farm, Agassiz BC — Catalogue of Fruit Trees under Test (Bulletin No. 3, 1900) (1900)
Bristol Canada Red Canada Redstreak Canada Rouge Donahoe Nonesuch Nonsuch Old Nonsuch Old Nonsuch of Massachusetts Old Nonsuch, of Mass. Poland Red Winter Richfield Nonsuch Richfield Nonsuch of Ohio Rote Canada Reinette Steel's Red Steele's Red Steele's Red Winter Steele's Red Winter of Mich. Welch's Spitzenberg Welsh's Spitzenberg Winter Nonsuch Roseau Sutton