← All varieties

Gravenstein

Apple

Origin & History

The Gravenstein is a German apple said to have been originally found in the Duke of Augustinberg's garden at Gravenstein, in Holstein, the original tree growing there in the middle of the eighteenth century. An alternative account holds that it derived its name from the garden of the castle of Grafenstein, in Schleswig, and Diel supposed it may have been introduced from Italy. Whatever its precise origin, it became a common apple throughout Germany and Sweden, and was received from thence into the English collections. Hovey (1852) considered it "undoubtedly of similar origin with the Red Astrachan and Duchess of Oldenburg, possessing the peculiar habit of growth, form of foliage, and texture of the fruit, which distinguish the German apples."

In a letter dated October 11, 1820, published in the New England Farmer, Judge Buel of Albany called attention to the importation of Gravenstein and other German apples, trees of which he had presented to the members of the Massachusetts Horticultural Society. In 1857 Captain DeWolfe stated that the Gravenstein was imported by him from Denmark in May, 1826, though in view of Buel's earlier letter it appears the variety was imported to the vicinity of Albany probably prior to 1826. After these early importations Gravenstein gradually found its way into cultivation in various portions of the country. Hovey wrote in 1852 that "it is at the present time considerably cultivated, though not to the extent its merits deserve." By Beach's time (1905), it had been pretty generally disseminated through New York state, though in most localities grown to a limited extent only, with its cultivation in commercial orchards gradually increasing in some sections, particularly in portions of the Hudson valley where fruit growers found it desirable for both domestic and foreign markets.

Hovey observed that but few of the great number of foreign varieties described in European pomological works possess much merit in comparison with American native kinds, but that "among these few, however, the Gravenstein undoubtedly stands at the head. It is a large as well as a most beautiful fruit, and possesses that crisp yet tender flesh, and that refreshing admixture of sweet and acid which characterize our most esteemed apples."

Tree

Tree large, very vigorous, productive to very productive. An early bearer (Downing, Beach, Encyclopedia). Form variously described: spreading (Warder, Downing), upright spreading to roundish and open (Beach), or upright with a somewhat pyramidal habit forming a large, round head (Hovey); Downing describes it as forming a large, broad head. Elliott describes a large, regular, round head with broad foliage. In many sections of New York the tree was regarded as not quite hardy, being somewhat subject to sunscald and canker (Beach). The Encyclopedia (1914) likewise notes the tree is not especially hardy. Beach describes it as a pretty reliable cropper.

Shoots and Wood. Shoots vigorous (Warder). Young wood reddish brown (Downing). Twigs medium to long, curved, moderately stout; internodes long (Beach). Bark brownish-red, mingled with olive-green, lightly streaked with scarf-skin; pubescent (Beach). Hovey describes the wood as brown purplish red, sprinkled with a few whitish dots, rather short-jointed, woolly at the ends; old wood dull brownish red. Annual shoots branch off horizontally, moderately stout, curved upwards at the end (Hovey). Elliott and Thomas describe the shoots as strong; Thomas adds that they become smooth and shining, ascending, while Elliott calls them smooth and upright.

Lenticels. Very scattering, medium to small, oblong, not raised (Beach).

Buds. Medium in size, plump, acute, free, pubescent (Beach). Hovey describes the buds as small, short, and flattened, with flower-buds of medium size.

Leaves. Long, rolled, showing the white underside (Warder). Hovey gives a more detailed description: large, ovate, somewhat cordate at the base, acuminate, the upper surface deep glossy green, little wavy, and rather sharply serrated; petioles medium length, about an inch long, rather stout. Elliott notes the foliage is broad.

Flowers. Large, pale; petals roundish, cupped (Hovey).

Fruit

Size

Large to above medium, fairly uniform in size but not in shape (Beach). Hovey gives dimensions of about three inches broad and two and a half inches deep.

Form

Oblate to roundish, somewhat irregular, broad at the base, slightly angular about the basin (Beach). Warder describes it as globular-oblate and angular. Downing calls it rather flattened, a little one-sided or angular, broadest at the base. Hovey describes it as roundish, irregular, angular on the sides, broadest at the base and narrowing to the crown, which is large, ribbed, and slightly depressed. Elliott says roundish flattened, a little irregular, somewhat ribbed, on the surface undulating. Thomas describes it as roundish, slightly oblate, obtusely and obscurely ribbed, surface a little wavy.

Stem

Short to medium, thick (Beach). Downing says quite short and strong, deeply set. Hovey describes it as very short, less than half an inch long, moderately stout, and deeply inserted. Thomas gives a length of three-quarters of an inch. Warder and Elliott both say short.

Cavity

Rather large, acute to acuminate, moderately deep to deep, rather narrow to broad, irregularly russeted (Beach). Warder describes it as deep and regular. Elliott calls it open and deep. Hovey says medium sized and somewhat uneven. Thomas says rather deep.

Calyx

Large, open or sometimes closed; lobes large, long, very broad, acute (Beach). Downing describes the calyx as large, closed, with segments long, irregular, and recurved. Hovey says the eye is large and open, with segments of the calyx large, broad, somewhat reflexed and woolly. Elliott describes open, half-reflexed segments. Thomas says the calyx is large. Warder, in contrast, describes the eye as small and closed.

Basin

Irregular, medium in depth to deep, medium to wide, obtuse to somewhat abrupt, wrinkled (Beach). Downing calls it wide, deep, and rather irregular. Hovey describes it as large, open, and furrowed. Elliott says rather deep, irregular, and ribbed. Thomas describes it as deep and narrow. Warder says medium and regular.

Skin

Thin, tender, slightly rough, greenish-yellow to orange-yellow overlaid with broken stripes of light and dark red; dots few, small, light; prevailing effect yellow striped (Beach). Downing describes the skin as greenish yellow at first, but becoming yellow, and beautifully dashed and pencilled and marbled with light and deep red and orange. Hovey calls it fair, smooth, with a greenish yellow ground of a waxen hue, distinctly streaked and pencilled with pale red, and lightly splashed with crimson, deepest on the sunny side. Elliott describes it as at first pale greenish, yellow ground, becoming rich yellow, beautifully striped and splashed with bright red; exposed to sun, red prevails and becomes of a dark hue, with a few faint light green dots. Warder describes the surface as smooth, yellow, partially covered with mixed and splashed scarlet, with rare dots. Thomas says striped and splashed with bright red on a yellow ground.

Flesh & Flavor

Yellowish, firm, moderately fine, crisp, moderately tender, juicy, sprightly subacid, aromatic, very good to best (Beach). Warder describes the flesh as yellow, fine grained, breaking, juicy, with sub-acid, aromatic flavor, quality best. Downing says tender and crisp, with a high-flavored, somewhat aromatic taste, very good. Hovey describes the flesh as yellowish white, rather coarse, crisp and very tender, with juice abundant, rich, subacid, sprightly and high flavored. Elliott says yellowish, crisp, tender, sub-acid, with a peculiar aromatic taste. Thomas calls it tender, juicy, very rich, sub-acid or rather acid, high flavored. Hovey praised "that crisp yet tender flesh, and that refreshing admixture of sweet and acid which characterize our most esteemed apples."

Core & Seeds

Core medium in size, strongly abaxile; cells open; core lines clasping the funnel cylinder; carpels broadly ovate, emarginate (Beach). Calyx tube large, conical to funnel-shape; stamens median (Beach). Seeds medium to large, medium in width, rather long, plump, acute to acuminate, medium brown (Beach). Warder describes the core as regular, globular or pointed toward the eye, closed, clasping, with seeds small and pointed. Hovey says the core is rather small and closed, with seeds of medium size. Elliott describes the core as large, capsules open, hollow, with seeds ovate pyriform and reddish brown.

Season

Season varies with latitude and altitude. Warder gives August and September. Elliott notes it is fit for cooking in August and eating in September and October. Hovey says ripe in September and keeps till December. Downing gives September and October. Beach says late September till early November. The Encyclopedia (1914) gives the range as last of August to first of November. Thomas says mid-autumn. The crop ripens continuously during a period of several weeks and should have two or three pickings (Beach), or perhaps four (Encyclopedia). When properly handled a considerable portion of the fruit may remain apparently sound much later than November, but the color fades and the quality and flavor deteriorate (Beach). Beach notes it stands up well in good dry cold storage. There is apt to be considerable loss from the dropping of the fruit before it is properly colored, and there is also a rather high percentage of low-grade or unmarketable fruit (Beach).

Uses

A dual-purpose table and kitchen apple (Warder). For culinary purposes perhaps unexcelled by any variety of its season (Beach). The Encyclopedia (1914) calls it good for dessert with no superior for culinary purposes. Downing describes it as a valuable apple for market or cooking, succeeding admirably wherever grown. It often sells at comparatively high prices (Beach, Encyclopedia). Hovey notes it comes in at a season when fine varieties are not overstocked, succeeding the Porter and supplying the table throughout October.

Subtypes & Variants

Several instances are known where bud sports of the Gravenstein have originated which bear highly colored red fruit, but in other respects are quite like the typical Gravenstein. Gaucher and Leroy each describe a Red Gravenstein. A Red Gravenstein which originated in Nova Scotia is cultivated under the name Banks (Beach). The Encyclopedia (1914) likewise mentions bud sports including Gaucher, Leroy, Red Gravenstein, and Banks.

Book Sources

Described in 7 period pomological works

Nursery Catalog Sources

Found in 88 catalogs (1845–1955) from Alabama, Arkansas, California, England, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Washington

View original book sources (8)

Gravenstein.

This fine European apple is said to have originated at Gravenstein, Holstein. It has long been in this country, where it succeeds very well. Tree vigorous, spreading, productive; Shoots vigorous; Leaves long, rolled, showing the white underside.

Fig. 132. — GRAVENSTEIN.

Fruit large, globular-oblate, angular; Surface smooth, yellow, partially covered with mixed and splashed scarlet; Dots rare. Basin medium, regular; Eye small, closed. Cavity deep, regular; Stem short. Core regular, globular, or pointed toward the eye, closed, clasping; Seeds small, pointed; Flesh yellow, fine grained, breaking, juicy; Flavor sub-acid, aromatic; Quality best; table and kitchen; Season, August, September.

— John A. Warder, American Pomology: Apples (1867)

Gravenstein. Grave Slije. A superb-looking German Apple, which originated at Gravenstein in Holstein, and is thought one of the finest apples of the North of Europe. It fully sustains its reputation here, and is, unquestionably, a fruit of first-rate quality. Tree very vigorous, spreading, forming a large, broad head. Very productive. An early bearer. Young wood reddish brown. Fruit large, rather flattened, and a little one-sided or angular, broadest at the base. Stalk quite short and strong, deeply set. Calyx large, closed, in a wide, deep, rather irregular basin. Segments long, irregular, recurved. Skin greenish yellow at first, but becoming yellow, and beautifully dashed and pencilled, and marbled with light and deep red and orange. Flesh tender and crisp, with a high-flavored, somewhat aromatic taste. Very good. September and October. A valuable apple for market or cooking, succeeding admirably wherever grown.

A.J. Downing, The Fruits and Fruit Trees of America (1900)

GRAVENSTEIN.

REFERENCES. 1. Forsyth, 1824:105. 2. Pom. Mag., 3:No. 98. 1830. col. pl. 3. London Hort. Soc. Cat., 1831:No. 489. 4. Kenrick, 1832:34. 5. Floy-Lindley, 1833:52. 6. Manning, 1838:53. 7. Ib., Mag. Hort., 7:45. 1841. 8. Downing, 1845:85. fig. 9. Horticulturist, 1:196. 1846. 10. Cole, 1849:110. fig. 11. Thomas, 1849:149. fig. 12. Horticulturist, 5:200. 1850. 13. Barry, 1851:284. 14. Emmons, Nat. Hist. N. Y., 3:32, 104. 1851. fig., col. pl. No. 28. 15. Hovey, 2:15. 1851. col. pl. 16. Ant. Pom. Soc. Cat., 1852. 17. Elliott, 1854:83. 18. Gregg, 1857:43. fig. 19. Hooper, 1857:41, 107, 111. 20. De Wolf and Hovey, Mag. Hort., 23:444. 1857. 21. Warder, 1867:487. fig. 22. Fitz, 1872:143, 149, 152. 23. Leroy, 1873:338. fig. 24. Horticulturist, 30:32. 1875. 25. Downing, 1881:11 index, app. 26. Hogg, 1884:96. 27. Wickson, 1889:243. 28. Lyon, Mich. Hort. Soc. Rpt., 1890:292. 29. Bailey, An. Hort., 1892:240. 30. Stinson, Ark. Sta. An. Rpt., 6:55. 1893. 31. Gaucher, 1894:No. 10. col. pl. 32. Saunders, Ont. Fr. Gr. Assn. An. Rpt., 27:51. 1895. 33. Amer. Gard., 16:381. 1895. fig. 34. Burrill and McCluer, Ill. Sta. Bul., 45:303. 1896. 35. Bunyard, Jour. Roy. Hort. Soc., 1898:354. 36. Can. Hort., 22:133. 1899. 37. Van Deman, Rural N. Y., 59:20. 1900. 38. Woolverton, Ont. Fr. Stas. An. Rpt., 8:8. 1901. figs. 39. Waugh, Vt. Sta. An. Rpt., 14:295. 1901. 40. Can. Hort., 25:167. 1902. fig. 41. Budd-Hansen, 1903:93. fig. 42. Bruner, N. C. Sta. Bul., 182:20. 1903. 43. Powell and Fulton, U. S. B. P. I. Bul., 48:143. 1903. 44. Beach and Clark, N. Y. Sta. Bul., 248:122. 1904.

SYNONYMS. Blumen-Calvill (31). Calville de Gravenstein (31). Calville Grafensteiner (23, 31). Diel's Sommerkonig (31). Early Congress (25). Grafen-Apfel (31). Grafensteiner (15, 23, 31). Grave Slige (23). Grave Slije (8, 15, 17, 31). GRAVENSTEIN (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 44). Gravenstein (31). GRAVENSTEINER (31). Gravensteiner (23). Gravenstine (31). Ohio Nonpareil (17, 23, 31). Paradies Apfel (31). Pomme Graefenstein (31). Prinsessin-Apfel (31). Sabine (31). Sabine of the Flemings (15, 23). Strohmer (31). Stromling (31). Tom Harryman (31).

Gravenstein is an apple of good size, attractive appearance and excellent quality. For culinary purposes it is perhaps unexcelled by any variety of its season. It often sells at comparatively high prices. In many sections of the state the tree is regarded as not quite hardy, being somewhat subject to sunscald and canker. It comes into bearing moderately early, is quite productive and a pretty reliable cropper. The crop ripens continuously during a period of several weeks and should have two or three pickings. Beginning in the latter half of September it continues in season till early November. When properly handled a considerable portion of the fruit may remain apparently sound much later than this but the color fades and the quality and flavor deteriorate. As compared with other varieties of its class it stands up well in good dry cold storage (44). There is apt to be considerable loss from the dropping of the fruit before it is properly colored and there is also a rather high percentage of low grade or unmarketable fruit. In spite of these serious faults its cultivation in commercial orchards is gradually increasing in some sections of the state, particularly in portions of the Hudson valley where fruit growers find it a desirable apple for both domestic and foreign markets.

Historical. The following excellent account of the history of this variety was given by Hovey in 1851 (15). "The origin of the Gravenstein remains in some doubt. It is said to have been originally found in the Duke of Augustinberg's garden at Gravenstein, in Holstein, and that the original tree was growing there in the middle of the last century; another statement is, that it derived its name from being found in the garden of the castle of Grafenstein, in Sleswick; and Diel says, that it was supposed by some to have been introduced from Italy. Be this as it may, it is a common apple throughout Germany and Sweden, and was received from thence into the English collections. It is undoubtedly of similar origin with the Red Astrachan and Duchess of Oldenburg, possessing the peculiar habit of growth, form of foliage, and texture of the fruit, which distinguish the German apples.

"At what time it was first introduced into our gardens we are not aware. But as neither Coxe or Thacher describe or name it, we suppose it was some time subsequent to the account given of it in the Transactions of the London Horticultural Society in 1822. It is at the present time considerably cultivated, though not to the extent its merits deserve."

In 1857 Captain DeWolfe stated that the Gravenstein was imported by him from Denmark in May, 1826 (20). In a letter dated October 11, 1820, published in the New England Farmer, Judge Buel, of Albany, called attention to the importation of Gravenstein and other German apples, trees of which he had presented to the members of the Massachusetts Horticultural Society. Hovey states that in view of this it appears that Gravenstein was imported to the vicinity of Albany probably prior to 1826 (20). After these early importations Gravenstein gradually found its way into cultivation in various portions of the country. For many years it has been pretty generally disseminated through New York state, but in most localities it is grown to a limited extent only.

TREE. Tree large, vigorous. Form upright spreading to roundish, open. Twigs medium to long, curved, moderately stout; internodes long. Bark brownish-red, mingled with olive-green, lightly streaked with scarf-skin; pubescent. Lenticels very scattering, medium to small, oblong, not raised. Buds medium in size, plump, acute, free, pubescent.

FRUIT. Fruit large to above medium, fairly uniform in size but not in shape. Form oblate to roundish, somewhat irregular, broad at the base, slightly angular about the basin. Stem short to medium, thick. Cavity rather large, acute to acuminate, moderately deep to deep, rather narrow to broad, irregularly russeted. Calyx large, open or sometimes closed; lobes large, long, very broad, acute. Basin irregular, medium in depth to deep, medium to wide, obtuse to somewhat abrupt, wrinkled. Skin thin, tender, slightly rough, greenish-yellow to orange-yellow overlaid with broken stripes of light and dark red. Dots few, small, light. Prevailing effect yellow striped. Calyx tube large, conical to funnel-shape. Stamens median. Core medium in size, strongly abaxile; cells open; core lines clasping the funnel cylinder. Carpels broadly ovate, emarginate. Seeds medium to large, medium in width, rather long, plump, acute to acuminate, medium brown. Flesh yellowish, firm, moderately fine, crisp, moderately tender, juicy, sprightly subacid, aromatic, very good to best. Season late September till early November.

RED TYPES OF THE GRAVENSTEIN. Several instances are known where bud sports of the Gravenstein have originated which bear highly colored red fruit, but in other respects are quite like the typical Gravenstein. Some of these sports have neither been described nor propagated but others of them have been introduced into cultivation under distinct names. Gaucher and Leroy each describe a Red Gravenstein. A Red Gravenstein which originated in Nova Scotia is now cultivated under the name Banks. For an account of this variety the reader is referred to Banks, page 14.

S.A. Beach, The Apples of New York, Vol. 2 (1905)

Gravenstein

The Gravenstein is one of the best apples in its season. It is good for dessert and has no superior for culinary purposes. The crop ripens continuously during a period of several weeks, and for that reason should have two, three, or perhaps four pickings. It is ready for use from the last of August to the first of November, depending on the latitude and altitude in which it is grown. Being regarded the best apple in its season, the fruit often sells for high prices in the markets. The tree is not especially hardy; but comes into bearing early and is quite productive.

Historical. In Hovey's account published in 1851, it is said, "The origin of the Gravenstein remains in some doubt." It is said to have been originally found in the Duke of Augustinberg's garden at Gravenstein in Holstein, and that the original tree was growing there in the middle of the last century (1750). Another statement is that it derived its name from being found in the garden of the castle of Grafenstein in Selswick; and Deil says

[Quince Apple. Apple of Commerce. Maxted Photo.]

that it was supposed by some to have been introduced from Italy. Be this as it may, it is a common apple throughout Germany and Sweden, and was received from thence into the English colonies.

Fruit large to above medium, fairly uniform in size but not in shape. Form oblate to roundish, somewhat irregular, broad at the base, slightly angular about the basin. Skin thin, tender, slightly rough, greenish yellow to orange yellow, overlaid with broken stripes of light and dark red. Dots few, small, light. Prevailing effect yellow striped.

There are several instances where bud sports have originated highly colored red fruit like the Gaucher, Leroy, Red Gravenstein and Banks.

— Granville Lowther (ed.), Encyclopedia of Practical Horticulture (1914)

THE GRAVENSTEIN APPLE.

Gravenstein. Transactions Lon. Hort. Soc., vol. iv. pl. xxi. Grave Slue, } According to Hort. Soc. Cat., 1842. Sabine of the Flemings, } Grafensteiner, of the Germans.

But few of the great number of foreign varieties of apples, which have been described and figured in European pomological works, appear to possess much merit in comparison with our native kinds. It is true, only a limited number have had a fair trial; but that number has been a selection from the very best, and few of them are sufficiently meritorious to retain a place in our gardens.

Among these few, however, the Gravenstein undoubtedly stands at the head. It is a large as well as a most beautiful fruit, and possesses that crisp yet tender flesh, and that refreshing admixture of sweet and acid which characterize our most esteemed apples. It comes in, too, at a season when we are not overstocked with fine varieties, succeeding the Porter, and supplying the table throughout the month of October.

The origin of the Gravenstein remains in some doubt. It is said to have been originally found in the Duke of Augustinberg's garden at Gravenstein, in Holstein, and that the original tree was growing there in the middle of the last century; another statement is, that it derived its name from being found in the garden of the castle of Grafenstein, in Sleswick; and Diel says, that it was supposed by some to have been introduced from Italy. Be this as it may, it is a common apple throughout Germany and Sweden, and was received from thence into the English collections. It is undoubtedly of similar origin with the Red Astrachan and Duchess of Oldenburg, possessing the peculiar habit of growth, form of foliage, and texture of the fruit, which distinguish the German apples.

At what time it was first introduced into our gardens we are not aware. But as neither Cox or Thatcher describe or name it, we suppose it was some time subsequent to the account given of it in the Transactions of the London Horticultural Society in 1822. It is at the present time considerably cultivated, though not to the extent its merits deserve.

The Gravenstein is a vigorous and healthy growing tree, attaining a good size, and bearing abundant crops.

Tree.—Vigorous, upright, with a somewhat pyramidal habit, but forming a large, round head; annual shoots branching off horizontally, moderately stout, curved upwards at the end.

Wood.—Brown purplish red, sprinkled with a few whitish dots, rather short-jointed, woolly at the ends; old wood, dull brownish red; buds, small, short, and flattened: Flower-buds, medium size.

Leaves.—Large, ovate, somewhat cordate at the base, acuminate, the upper surface deep glossy green, little wavy, and rather sharply serrated; petioles, medium length, about an inch long, rather stout.

Flowers.—Large, pale; petals, roundish, cupped.

Fruit.—Large, about three inches broad, and two and a half deep: Form, roundish, irregular, angular on the sides, broadest at the base and narrowing to the crown, which is large, ribbed, and slightly depressed: Skin, fair, smooth, with a greenish yellow ground, of a waxen hue, distinctly streaked and pencilled with pale red, and lightly splashed with crimson, deepest on the sunny side: Stem, very short, less than half an inch long, moderately stout, and deeply inserted in a medium sized, somewhat uneven cavity: Eye, large, open, and moderately sunk in a large, open and furrowed basin; segments of the calyx large, broad, somewhat reflexed and woolly: Flesh, yellowish white, rather coarse, crisp and very tender: Juice, abundant, rich, subacid, sprightly and high flavored: Core, rather small, closed: Seeds, medium size.

Ripe in September and keeps till December.

— C.M. Hovey, The Fruits of America (1852)

Gravenstein.

King of Pippins, erroneously, | Grave Slije.

Foreign. A variety indispensable to every collection, succeeding finely on all soils, annually productive, fruit always fair, fit for cooking in August, and eating in September and October; shoots, strong, smooth, upright. Tree, large, regular, round head, foliage broad.

Fruit, large; form, roundish flattened, a little irregular, somewhat ribbed, on surface undulating; color, at first pale greenish, yellow ground, becoming rich yellow, beautifully striped, and splashed with bright red; exposed to sun, red prevails, and becomes of a dark hue, beautiful, few faint light green dots; stem, short; cavity, open, deep; calyx, with open half reflexed segments; basin, rather deep, irregular, ribbed; flesh, yellowish, crisp, tender, sub-acid, with a peculiar aromatic taste; core, large, capsules open, hollow; seeds, ovate pyriform, reddish brown.

— F.R. Elliott, The Western Fruit Book (1865)

Gravenstein.* Rather large, roundish, slightly oblate, obtusely and obscurely ribbed, surface a little wavy; striped and splashed with bright red on a yellow ground; stalk three-quarters of an inch long; cavity rather deep; calyx large; basin deep, narrow; flesh tender, juicy, very rich, sub-acid or rather acid, high flavored. Mid-autumn. Productive, handsome, and excellent. Fine in all localities. Shoots strong, becoming smooth and shining, ascending. Fig. 391. German.

— John J. Thomas, The American Fruit Culturist (1903)

large, very fine, quality, prolific - Sept.-Nov.

— Thomas Rivers & Son, Thomas Rivers Catalogue of Fruits (1914) (1914)
Banks Blumen-Calvill Calville Grafensteiner Calville de Gravenstein Diel's Sommerkonig Early Congress German Grafen-Apfel Grafensteiner Grave Slige Grave Slije Grave Slue Gravensteiner Gravenstine King of Pippins Ohio Nonpareil Paradies Apfel Pomme Graefenstein Prinsessin-Apfel Sabine Sabine of the Flemings Strohmer Stromling Tom Harryman Gloria Mundi Ohio Nonpareil Rosenhager Myer's Nonpareil Myer's Cogswell Banks White Spanish Reinette